Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The tarballs mismatching from the git tree is a feature, not a bug. Projects that use submodules may want to include these and projects using autoconf may want to generate and include the configure script.


> The tarballs mismatching from the git tree is a feature, not a bug.

A feature which allowed the exploit to take place, let's put it that way.

Over here: https://gist.github.com/thesamesam/223949d5a074ebc3dce9ee78b...

> The release tarballs upstream publishes don't have the same code that GitHub has. This is common in C projects so that downstream consumers don't need to remember how to run autotools and autoconf. The version of build-to-host.m4 in the release tarballs differs wildly from the upstream on GitHub.

Multiple suggestions on that thread on how that's a legacy practice that might be outdated, especially in the current climate of cyber threats.

Someone even posted a more thorough gist on what could be done to increase transparency and reduce discrepancies between tarballs and repos: https://gist.github.com/smintrh78/97b5cb4d8332ea4808f25b47c8...



"lol"

> Those days are pretty much behind us. Sure, you can compile code and tweak software configurations if you want to--but most of the time, users don't want to. Organizations generally don't want to, they want to rely on certified products that they can vet for their environment and get support for. This is why enterprise open source exists. Users and organizations count on vendors to turn upstreams into coherent downstream products that meet their needs.

> In turn, vendors like Red Hat learn from customer requests and feedback about what features they need and want. That, then, benefits the upstream project in the form of new features and bugfixes, etc., and ultimately finds its way into products and the cycle continues.

"and when the upstream is tainted, everyone drinks poisoned water downstream, simple as that!"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: