Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Apple's "privacy" is really privacy from people that are not Apple. Apple has access to location logs via maps and location services, the contents of your photos, iMessage contents, the history of every app usage, etc as the default settings set for most things via iCloud backup, which the vast majority of users leave on. They were almost going to deploy on device scanning that you couldn't opt out of with the few photos that don't end up on iCloud.

All of their devices don't work if they don't constantly phone home to Apple. For the devices to be anywhere near useful, you need an apple id which requires KYC payment methods attached for them or a KYC phone number.



> Apple's "privacy" is really privacy from people that are not Apple.

Sort of, but misleading…

> Apple has access to location logs via maps and location services

There are published policies about how this data gets aggregated+anonymized and then used. Care is taken to ensure data is not linked to individuals.

> The contents of your photos, iMessage contents, the history of every app usage, etc as the default settings set for most things via iCloud backup

Most people want these things backed up. Apple doesn’t just dive through data. Anything that even approaches the description of dealing with user data is carefully vetted. A big difference between Apple and other large tech companies is the internal boundaries for access to any data. It’s strict and limited by design. Apple has fought back against law enforcement for access to personal data or technology to allow governments to carte blanche access devices.

> They were almost going to deploy on device scanning that you couldn't opt out of with the few photos that don't end up on iCloud.

You are referencing the CSAM scanning for known child pornography based on international databases that was tuned for highly unlikely false-positive rates with a small group of reviewers to further reduce any chance of false-positives? Yeah, total travesty… wouldn’t want to do anything about THAT problem. (/s)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: