Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is going to turn out to be the new phrenology, completely flawed, but it won't stop phobic types from using it to "prove" their antisocial theories.


If it works well isn't it not similar to phrenology?


I think the implication is it doesn't actually work well. Running hard-to-explain models on brain scans has a history of producing papers which fail to reproduce, there were a bunch of bunk results in fMRI research a few years ago.


Exactly, it's going to turn out that it didn't work well but it will still get used harmfully.


While skepticism is healthy, I don't understand how you can say with certainty it will not work.

A hypothetical technology that could very accurately determine the sex of a brain would seem to be a boon for transgendered people. Early detection could mean better treatment and less suffering with fewer cases of desisting.


I do hope for your optimistic scenario, but I do not expect it.


It would be much more likely to reveal that the idea of a "female brain in a male body" or vice versa is incorrect.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: