Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What is your purpose with these posts?



My point is to help you not forget your compassion. All this talk about agency is nothing if you don’t have the luck to go along with it. So if you see someone who’s homeless, don’t talk to them about their agency. Just help them.


> Just help them.

Trivializing homelessness like this doesn't help, and I strongly disagree that "agency is nothing" to unhoused people. There are many free resources available, but the organizations providing them often don't have the capacity to efficiently allocate them to those in need, due to difficulties with reach, etc.

Escaping poverty is a function of others' generosity (luck) but also agency; you can't do it without some amount of self-belief and proactivity and exposing yourself to opportunities for aid. But it's very difficult and a lot of people give up.


They didn't say 'agency is nothing', you took that out of context. They said 'talk about agency is nothing without luck'

It's like me saying a bowl of soup is useless without a spoon. And you go quote me as, "a bowl of soup is useless".

You are arguing with yourself


I’m homeless. And I never said agency is nothing. I am saying that luck is everything. For instance, I’m unlucky to be a man who is homeless.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: