Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Affinity has various workflow interrupting issues and missing features, from things Adobe figured out 20 years ago. And to be clear, I'd love Affinity to succeed at being a more serious competitor.

Just a handful from one notes file:

- No percentage document scaling drop-down option, despite featuring some uncommonly used units for design work. Instead it's hidden as a non-discoverable feature where you enter a percentage in the pixel field and it auto-converts to that absolute pixel value in-situ...

- Re-opening a document doesn't restore the state of opened/closed groups in the layer panel

- Lack of keyboard navigation for UI dialogs

- Lack of smart objects equivalent (only workaround is placing pre-existing documents).

- Can't paste clipboard contents directly as mask. In PS this is trivial using quick masks and the way they handle masks in general. Brought up in topics as old as 8 years. Agreed with sibling that masking needs love.

- Up until v2 (afaict) there was no way to disable layer auto select for the move tool

- Default zoom when opening documents can't be set to 100%

- Only has binary layer lock option, rather than separate move/edit/etc locking

- Lack of blend/interpolation of vector paths feature (another old and popular requested feature Adobe has had for decades)

- Have experienced random crashes for simple actions (opening menus, preferences, pressing warp transform, dragging layers).

- Vector node editing takes a dive in speed after just a dozen paths in a single layer. Only workaround is using multiple paths instead.

The list goes on. That said Affinity is usable if you don't mind dozens of little things that have been ironed out and included for a long time in PS. And to be fair, it's very fairly priced as such.




I really, really, really want to use the Affinity suite for more stuff, but just the other day when I was trying to knock up a basic drawing of something that exists in real life (a bicycle frame) I found that Designer couldn't draw a line of X length at N angle. It just... didn't have the option.

All I wanted to do was draw a few lines of given lengths and angles and join their ends. Then overlay another set of the same in different colors so I could see how the two groupings compared visually.

But... I couldn't.

That's such a fundamental part of Illustrator that I guess I'll be going back to it.


Can't you just draw a line of X length and then rotate it to N?


You have to draw a line, then edit all it's parameters. It's a pain.


True.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: