Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

From time to time I used grammarly to adjust my writing style when sending an important e-mail. I paid a subscription to it.

The day I typed my first question into ChatGPT I cancelled my gmrly subscription. If they'd a public stock I'll be shorting it so hard.



Why? The ChatGPT interface is not integrated with an editor and not really tailored for writing. I'd wager that most of the current Grammarly users would rather pay for a tailored tool than a chat window that excels at schooling you and refusing to do anything that doesn't align with OpenAI's sprawling brand safety rules.

Of course, GPT-4 can be molded into an editing-centric companion, but I bet Grammarly is already working on that, and they might end up paying OpenAI for the technology.

Brand recognition means that it's a lot easier for Grammarly to build that product than for a random third party to break through.


> The ChatGPT interface is not integrated with an editor

But all the editors where Grammarly is integrated are owned by Google/Microsoft/etc., who can natively implement a writing-tailored AI as a feature.


> Grammarly is already working on that, and they might end up paying OpenAI for the technology.

Unless they get a very good deal using the GPT-4 API might end up too expensive for their use case.


I use both products (I'm also an author so YMMV).

Grammarly has the UX down. For authors, gpt doesn't compare.


I found Grammarly to be atrociously bad when dealing with anything slightly technical in nature. It would keep flagging jargon as errors. I was convinced that their $100M+ raise had to be some Adam Neuman-tier grift


I worry that all individuality will be stripped from our communications. Let people have idiosyncrasies.


I enjoyed Grammarly and I'm sure they enjoyed mapping my prose for training purposes.

When I began to consistently compose 1000+ word passages, all while never triggering a red squiggle, I realized I'd gotten everything I needed from the tool and I uninstalled the addins. (I was a fully paid single user, btw.)


Totally agree. You get so much of personality from honest, unedited emails and messages.

Communication isn’t just information. It’s also how relationships are built. I get an email that was run through a dozen rounds of spell check and AI wizardry and I won’t even know who you really are.


I don't know about that, but they definitely seem to have a bottomless supply of money to spend on advertising.


Isn’t grammarly in a relatively good place as it already has an audience, a market fit and a way to expand its products with AI?


I think their biggest issue is that every place where Grammarly is used (e.g. email clients, word processors) is owned by a much larger corporation with a huge investment in AI that can pretty easily launch a Grammarly replacement as a native feature.


True. At the same time this seems unrelated to “The day I typed my first question into ChatGPT”.


Check out editGPT for an improved UI




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: