Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's the old-age disconnect between the marketing, the claims and the actual functionality.

For example, the title claims that it's a file explorer. However, someone in the comments shows that it fails at actually exploring files. Something which even an alpha project would not fail to do considering the claim.

Only when you read through the marketing copy and the comments, you realise that it's a hybrid cloud/local/cross-device Dropbox that creates a view of your files across systems/locations, and only once it's done that, only then can it do the actual file exploring. At least for now.



age old


Well, English evolves...


I personally prefer "age old". I was going for the same opening statement as the original comment :)


The title doesn't claim it IS a file explorer, it is an alpha version of something that aims to become a file explorer (for some definition of "explorer"). That's exactly the point of the OP?


I mean the title of this HN post is...

> Spacedrive – an open source cross-platform file explorer (github.com/spacedriveapp)

Then the github file about section says...

> Spacedrive is an open source cross-platform file explorer, powered by a virtual distributed filesystem written in Rust.

Then the github page opens by saying...

> Spacedrive - A file explorer from the future.

And claims it offers...

> a free file management experience like no other.

So I think we can forgive people for thinking it is a file explorer!


Completely ignoring

> UPDATE: Spacedrive is under active development, we are in the pre-alpha stage, with builds occasionally released via GitHub actions, official alpha coming soon.


Yeah, but considering it says "this is a file explorer" a load of times, saying "it doesn't claim to be a file explorer" isn't right.


A file explorer that doesn't explore files in alpha is not a file explorer ;)


You'll have to check back when it gets to alpha then, since it doesn't claim to be there yet.


you're not wrong but perhaps being a bit unfair.

the project page has that front and center, it's only really the submission title that's implying otherwise.


I was actually thinking about exactly this when I read the headline. Reading this is disappointing




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: