Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The US spent a sizable chunk of it’s GDP on the moon missions


An average of 2.5% per year for 10 years. It would be like spending $575B per year now on a percentage of GDP basis.

You can do a lot of things with that money. Now we're talking about missions doing it for a once off $100M. So yes, massive progress has been made.


I think people do not give the shoulders that SpaceX stands on as much credit, some do of course, but the general populace doesn't think that way like those that are space nerds. NASA tried things, ULA tried things, Russia tried things, ESA tried things, and then SpaceX comes along and gets make decisions with all of that historical knowledge. This isn't an indictment on SpaceX, but acknowledging that historical money spent wasn't wasted. Space and rocket R&D is expensive, but it's cheap if you can have it funded by the tax payer. Not having the burden of requiring Congressional approval also avoids the moving at the pace of a herd of turtles.


Not nearly as much as it spent in military operations.

Apollo is a wonder of soft power - The US inspired countless children all over the world with those voyages. In terms of international good will, it was extremely cheap.


> Not nearly as much as it spent in military operations.

The entire space program was a military program wrapped in a very successful propaganda program.

It showed off US technological and engineering prowess and showed the US as advancing human culture and progress. It also greatly advanced US rocketry and led to rapid advancements in the design of ICBMs and their countermeasures (see Reagan's "Star Wars" programme). The entire space race was motivated by the belief that losing ground to the Soviet Union in spaceflight meant losing real strategic ground in military capabilities - a belief that was probably correct.


That's true, but it still inspired many people of the concept of peaceful space exploration. And I think it is still amazing, that despite the war, russian tech and US tech and personal are still cooperating in space today, even though that seems to be fading out.


The point of soft power is that you do with propaganda and diplomacy (and also building schools and hospitals) what less clever people would do through war. It's also much cheaper than war and gets us to cool places such as the Moon and Mars.

It really should be a no-brainer.

The only downside is that it takes a lot longer than war.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: