Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

A lot of people going on about the game controller, which itself wouldn't bother me if there was a direct connection way to control it too (aka via the touchscreens).

What bothers me more and is clear as day in those pictures are things like the screws into the carbon fiber pressure hull holding the screens up. There was someone (ex test engineer?) on reddit yesterday talking about a few things, but what really stuck out was how he mentioned there were a lot of questionable decisions being made that made him nop out of the project. And others mentioning simple things like painting it orange so it can be found on the surface easier were simply not being done.

So, while its possible the surface ship didn't have a sensitive hydrophone recording the dive, which seems almost impossible so i'm going to assume it does, everyone seems focused on how they should be able to hear it implode. Meaning it is drifting about somewhere...

But, I wonder, it seems quite possible to me that the thing simply sprung a leak, and flooded out in a matter of seconds rather than imploding. Once that happened none of the fail safes to surface would work because its likely not buoyant enough once full of water. A microscopic pinhole would probably ablate really fast, but would be completely unstoppable.

Given the hull is only 5" thick, even a 1/2" screw on the inside would be a significant percentage of the way through already.




That's just a decorative shell. You really think they drilled into their pressure hull?


I mean how should I know? The point is that I suspect there could be another option, which is that the pressure hull could have failed without imploding.

So, yes it seems insane, and having seen pictures which look both like that is a liner and ones where it looks like its not, I don't know. There is very clearly an outer shell offset from the pressure hull. Whats on the inside isn't as clear, but I'm not sure why they would be running cables out of the floor when they could just be running them out closer to the arm/etc if there is space behind.

Although from a human comfort perspective, I'm not sure why there isn't a little foot well/bench either. There is obviously stuff under the floor, but it also looks fairly hollow too.


> That’s just a marketing strategy. You really think they believe it’s unsinkable?

Although I would be surprised if they drilled into the hull, I wouldn’t be THAT surprised.


There is no way for a leak to happen without implosion. At 400 atmospheres a hairline crack is total destruction in less than a second.


Isn't a leak at that depth one of the main causes of implosion?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: