Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is definitely not good news for iPhone users. The thing with lightning is that it is fucking robust. USB-C may not be as bad as the micro-USB but it is still more fragile than lightning. People should be able to choose, if you love One Connector To Rule’em all just get and Android phone.


My personal experience is just the opposite; I have a number of children (more than the average number of kids), and I replace lightning cables more frequently than USB-C cables. And I do buy both Apple lightning cables and 3rd party ones. In my experience the cable case between the cable and the metallic connector tends to crack and degrade faster than USB-C equivalents. And the USB-C cables tend to be cheaper too.


> USB-C may not be as bad as the micro-USB but it is still more fragile than lightning

Is it though? Wouldn't we be hearing endless noise about how fragile android ports are if it was really that much worse? I've never heard any complaints about the USBC port from any android users in the news or anecdotally, even though most major phones are C now


Maybe to put you mind a little bit at ease anecdotally, I never had a USB-c plug or socket fail on me even with intense (ab)use. The same is true for my immediate family

It probably happens though.

I had cheap-o cables break but this is hardly the fault of usb-c


> I had cheap-o cables break

USB-C is supposedly designed in such a way that the (cheap) cable is more likely to break, not the (expensive) port.


It is. The springs which hold the cable in are in the plug, whereas they are in the socket for lighting. These springs are effectively consumable components.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: