I think someone more knowledgeable than me should reply to this, but my understanding is that most medicine is still too complex, with too little data to reliably make machine judgement. We don’t have the training data.
The comment is also uneccessarily confrontational. There are plenty of areas in medicine where checklist and sops have been widely adopted.
> [...] my understanding is that most medicine is still too complex, with too little data to reliably make machine judgement.
Indeed! I should have been clearer: I'm not suggesting any kind of AI / ML stuff — rather, only that where there is an established and uncontroversial best practice process for, e.g., diagnosing and treating X (which there often is), then I would hope for there to be a requirement to make a record of the path a doctor took to the conclusion, including a record any deviations like not ordering some standard test that most doctors would before starting a patient on Y. It could literally be a printed flowchart with check boxes on it and room for comments. The goal is to make the cowboys out there a little more accountable (incentivise doing things by the book), and to stop treating vague notions of "professional judgement" (a common protest against doing things by the book, I hear) as sufficient reason for ignoring the consensus best practice or simply forgetting important steps.
> The comment is also uneccessarily confrontational.
Fair call. I suppose ranting and raving doesn't really help anything. But I sincerely believe that a significant part of the problem is the defensiveness that tends to arise when a person is told (or it is implied): you are fallible. This tool will help to catch your mistakes, and make you more effective. I'm sure this happens in every industry, and I see working with that as 90÷ of the challenge.
> There are plenty of areas in medicine where checklist and sops have been widely adopted.
Yep, I agree wholeheartedly. And it saves lives. Hospitals in particular have made huge improvements to patient care/survival in this way, and continue to do so every year with new initiatives. I just think there are still a lot of, uh, exciting opportunities for future excellence. :)