Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Powell's been clear that the purpose of the rate hikes is to destroy demand until it matches what the economy can currently supply – this is practically a direct quote from his last press conference.

Supply and demand are always interchangeable when it comes to prices. We might compare supply (real GDP) to trend, and find it's been low, and conclude there's a supply and not a demand problem.[1] But the Fed is a bank and can't do much about supply.

Another question is whether inflation is actually high. There was a sharp change in the CPI last June.[2] Measuring from February 2022 still gives 6.0% but measuring from June gives 3.5%/year. There's also the question of inflation stability (2nd derivative of prices), and things have been pretty smooth since June.

So should the Fed crash the economy to try to bring stable 3.5% inflation down to 2%? Probably not. But the bigger question is: What can we do to increase supply?

[1] 1.7%/year 2022Q4/2019Q4 versus 2.6%/year 2019Q4/2016Q4 or 4.7%/year 1999Q4/1996Q4 etc.

[2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CPIAUCSL




I’m a bit confused by this comment.

You state that supply and demand are interchangeable they are not, a classic example would be the elasticity of a specific demand or market.

Then you say that the fed cannot do anything about the supply which isn’t correct at least if you are talking about the supply of money increasing the interest rates can reduce the supply of money within a given economy.


"Supply" here does not refer to money, but to physical goods and services.

A price change by can be caused by changes in supply, demand, or both. Additional information is needed to determine which. In the present situation it seems demand is 'normal' but supply is constrained.


That doesn’t make supply and demand interchangeable.


Agreed, nice to see someone talking about recent inflation figures. I think the real issue remains the labour market, it's not clear if companies are labour hoarding still or we are somehow amidst a massive shortage. Anything you do to try to increase supply is counter-productive if you don't have workers to do it..




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: