Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

we don't like fediverse because its a bad soultion, federation combines the negatives of centralization (censorship) and decentralization (disparat userbases with few users ).



Censorship seems like a non-problem on mastodon. If you are using someone else's server, and you break their rules, you'll lose your account. Just try another server. If you run your own server you make the rules. Other servers and users may block/mute your server but some may not. If everyone blocks your server and no one else joins your server, then maybe no one wants to hear you. You are not entitled to force people to listen to you.


you don't see how that doesn't compare to twitter in terms of functionality? the great thing of twitter is that you have a unified userbase that can interact and discourse on a single platform, if every 10 people have their own walled off server this is more like a groupchat than twitter


who is "we"?


we, the 'people here forgetting that the fediverse exists'


The censorship model is mostly the same, right? If you don't self-host, your host can censor your communication and refuse to relay or peer certain messages.


also disparat-ness is literally the essence of the whole internet, what are you even talking about?




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: