Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Unlike bake pads, these brushes are conductive. So their dust should react to magnetic fields, which are everywhere in these motors. I would expect the dust to settle or cake onto any number of other metal surfaces rather than drift through the air like brake pad dust.



Conductive metals does not necessarily also mean magnetic. Aluminium is just one example, conductive but not magnetic.


The brushes are almost certainly graphite, which actually isn't a metal.

Also graphite is diamagnetic, so strong magnets actually push it away.


Since we're speculating, the brushes could also be some harder material, with Carbon Nanotubes impregnated, or graphene infused and coated, etc.

Also, although I don't have the numbers for your issue about strong magnets pushing it away, I've found you need REALLY strong B Fields to do this. In other words, are we sure this is an effect that is at play here? (I'm asking)


Or add magnetic plugs to capture the dust. https://www.lislecorp.com/oem-products-division/magnetic-plu...


Even the title says "No magnets"


No magnets doesn't mean no magnetic fields. I believe they were referring to permanent magnets. An electric motor without any magnetic fields would be a very odd device.


Thanks for the clarification!


And a motor with a static magnetic field is just as weird.


Ion drive thrusters. Not sure how one would translate them into a car, although there have been some on model aircraft, but they are a type of motor with a static magnetic field.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: