Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Airbags aren’t supposed to go off in every crash. They’re primarily intended to provide some protection for unbelted passengers. Thus the original name SRS - “supplemental restraint system”.

In you are belted… most crashes you’d prefer it not go off, subjected you to any or all of: Powder burns, hearing damage, major dental destruction.



I think you may have gotten that wrong. Airbags are worse if the seatbelt is not worn. The timing for it firing takes into account that a seatbelt restrains the forward movement of the person. No seatbelt means moving forward quicker which means getting the full brunt of the airbag. Best case whiplash, otherwise a broken neck or similar.

At least that is what I have learned and which sounds reasonable.


I dimly seem to remember that there might be differing strategies in place in some parts of the world (maybe something like US vs. Europe?): In some places seatbelts aren't assumed in determining the airbag timings, whereas elsewhere the timing and triggering level are optimised based on the assumption that seatbelts are being used.


I don't think your point and their point are mutually exclusive:

- no seatbelt, you want the airbag to catch you (better than no airbag)

- with a seatbelt, ideally the airbag doesn't (need to?) go off, but if it is necessary you'll be glad of it


If there's blood, I think it's fair to say they should have gone off. I'd have those airbags checked and possibly replaced.

> They’re primarily intended to provide some protection for unbelted passengers

I don't think they're meant for unbelted passengers; they should be belted first. I once saw a program about the difference between regular airbags and airbags designed to be used without a seatbelt, and the latter were enormous monstrosities that could knock you out. They were determined to be a bad idea. (I wish I knew where I saw this, but it was decades ago and I don't.)


Your head can still hit the dash if you have a seatbelt. It holds your body, not your head. And then there's things like side airbags, etc.


Supplementary is in that it supplements your main restraint - the seat belt.

They should always go off if the front of the car is damaged as the description here.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: