I don't think I said Coinbase should be committed to decentralization. What I will say is more nuanced: if Coinbase and other exchanges aren't committed to decentralization, then you and I have good reason to distrust those exchanges' motives.
From the perspective of an individual investor in cryptocurrencies, decentralization is the entire benefit of cryptocurrencies.
Hacker News isn't a place where this will be popular to say this, but some regulations are good--they exist to protect from scams and obvious economic flaws.
Some regulations are misguided too. Decentralized currencies by their unregulatable nature avoid all regulations: good regulations and bad regulations. If you have reason to avoid the bad regulations, then cryptocurrencies are a good investment for you.
A centralized cryptocurrency is the worst of both worlds. It's (temporarily) unregulated, but it's not unregulatable. That means that investors don't get the benefits of avoiding the bad regulations, because in the long run, centralized cryptocurrencies can be brought into the regulation fold. But it also means that investors don't get the benefit of good regulations, because a scammer can exit long before their crypto gets regulated.
That's a pretty high-level, general view, but this plays out in a lot of specific ways, including what has happened with FTX.
From the perspective of an individual investor in cryptocurrencies, decentralization is the entire benefit of cryptocurrencies.
Hacker News isn't a place where this will be popular to say this, but some regulations are good--they exist to protect from scams and obvious economic flaws.
Some regulations are misguided too. Decentralized currencies by their unregulatable nature avoid all regulations: good regulations and bad regulations. If you have reason to avoid the bad regulations, then cryptocurrencies are a good investment for you.
A centralized cryptocurrency is the worst of both worlds. It's (temporarily) unregulated, but it's not unregulatable. That means that investors don't get the benefits of avoiding the bad regulations, because in the long run, centralized cryptocurrencies can be brought into the regulation fold. But it also means that investors don't get the benefit of good regulations, because a scammer can exit long before their crypto gets regulated.
That's a pretty high-level, general view, but this plays out in a lot of specific ways, including what has happened with FTX.