Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is there some specific advantage gained irl by hugging the wall like this? I can’t tell from the video what he achieved by it.


Do you see how fast he is going compared to the other cars? They are going as fast as they can without losing grip and spinning out as they go round the corner. He has the wall supporting him around the corner and could floor the accelerator in top gear.


Thanks for explaining that - I saw the video and was wondering "why are the other cars going so slow, is there a traffic jam?"


These cars don't seem to stick to the ground like they do in F1, so I guess they need to slow down a lot for the corner just like regular cars. Except for the guy who uses the wall to push him through the corner.


I get that he’s not going to slide off the track, but I don’t understand how he wouldn’t be slowed by the friction of the side of his car against the wall, though


During the course of the race bits of rubber come off the tires and form what is basically a rubbery gravel. The racing line is cleared of it by the passage of the cars. Get down too low or up too high and you start sliding like you would on gravel. So he went high, accepted the slippery-ness and used the wall to keep him going the right direction as he kept the pedal down.

On the racing line, even with a clean track, they still need grip to turn -- he didn't.

Also to note that as it is the end of the race, they aren't on fresh tires and probably most/all of the field didn't have the full grip they would during other portions of the race.


Speed through the turn is limited by lateral forces. The wall can provide more lateral force than the tires can. Yes, there's friction, but the cars are fiberglass, it's pretty slippery against a smooth painted wall (and they have a ton of power).


He is slowed down by the friction of the side of his car against the wall. And probably by bits of his car being torn away as it slowly disintegrates. But the engines on these cars are powerful and can easily overcome those effects.


They should add wheels on sides as well to reduce lateral wall frictions!


I'm not sure small wheels would really be an improvement, and large wheels would weigh a lot. So it's entirely possible that a smooth surface is actually the best approach here.


2 Skateboard wheels embedded in the bodywork, to touch the wall front and rear, and off to the races.


He is slowed, but the other drivers are slowed more by the need to keep traction in the turn.


nitro_force - friction_force > max_force_before_you_slip_on_that_turn


I bet he was close to passing out on that turn, much like a fighter jet pilot can experience when they pull too many g's in a turn.


Okay but why didn’t anyone try this before? They just didn’t think of it? What made it a good idea this time but not any other time if it’s faster?


Its insanely dangerous. Really just neigh-criminally stupid.

Any little lip in the siding on the wall could have caused him to flip or twirl about or get speared or launched his engine all over the place. The walls are designed to keep people safe, including the fans. They are fantastically well engineered and made. But, if he had caught the wall wrong and was catapulted into the stands, he may have killed a lot of people, let alone the danger to other drivers, let alone to himself. The various safety systems, of which the wall was but one, aren't made for that move and could very easily have been compromised in very bad ways.

I mean, it was awesome to watch, just incredibly cool. I'm glad it worked for him, he's in the history books for that move for sure. I can totally see NASCAR evolving to utilize that move in the future.

But he put many lives at more risk than anyone was expecting in such a kinetic sport.


I think just this year the body design on the cars became strong enough to try this. He also risked a yellow flag being thrown which would have disqualified any passing afterward. But they weren't quick enough with that lol.


The obvious one is that it ruins the car, at the end of the video you see his car is stopped on the track, presumably he broke some control arms and can't drive it back to the pits.

So it works once, then you're out, and you have to hope you pull it off safely. It was a massive risk, not all courses have a wall that wouldn't have wrecked the car. He mentions that part in the video.


He actually drove back to the pits OK, amazingly enough: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=27S42Y5km4I


That is pretty crazy. I can't imagine he kept his wheel alignment which would have been impactful if he had to keep racing, but it's impressive the suspension arms survived that. Maybe the new gen cage contacts before the wheels and they took most of the force?


I wonder if they modified the car for this at all? I've gotta imagine that he at least discussed the possibility of doing this with his crew before he went and did it.


He did discuss it with his crew with five laps to go, so it wasn't spur of the moment but pretty close.


Any recordings of this part?


The 2022 “NextGen” cars are significantly stiffer than prior cars; it’s possible that they are stiff enough to be better able to run the full half lap without getting stuck, but I more suspect no one seriously considered it.

Even with Nextgen cars, it’s a last half-lap move at most.


I also suspect nobody seriously considered it or thought they could get away with it. If they don't add rules to stop it, you will see people welding bumpers or even wheels to the sides of their cars to take advantage.


IMHO they should rule it out changing the wall construction in some way that it no longer gives an advantage. E.g. attaching TecPro barriers to it.


I think they should design the walls to make this easier and folks should put wheels on the side. Let’s go crazy, that was awesome.


If everyone has side wheel, it would get boring fast. The one that can hug the wall first win.


It'll be too hard on the driver's brains as well


Just race in a giant sewer pipe, I guess, heh.


Getting into the wall usually means a flat tire or at least being slowed down considerably. I don’t think you could do this on a superspeedway track because the forces and friction would just destroy the car before the turn was over. On a short track it looks to be a different story.


It was the last corner of the last lap - hugging the wall damages your car but because he didn't actually need to tap the brakes he just kept on going, round the wall faster than the others.


If this means you can take the corner faster, why not just do it all the time and make sure the side of your car is strong enough to withstand it?


The real answer is it only makes for good entertainment once, so it gets banned immediately.

If it had a real potential to spice the game (like allowing foot hits in volleyball) it would be integrated in the rules with some limitation (for instance you can only do it if you’re way behind)


It's not possible to build a car that strong under Nascar rules. The cars are mostly standardized with only minor differences allowed between teams.


Does Nascar disallow mounting a few luggage wheels on the right side of your car? :)


It probably would violate the external profile standards, even if the regulators wouldn't understand the purpose on first seeing it.


How much camber is allowed on the right wheels though, can you go full hella-flush? Asking for a friend :)


I considered this first. But I imagine the camber change would ruin the insides of the tires so fast that it wouldn't be worth the wall rolling benefits...

Perhaps a better idea would be some kind of aerodynamic change which would result in a trapped pressure area on the right side when it is close to the wall. Maybe some kind of concave side.


An F1 style 'wall-effect' skirt with a side mounted exhaust would do the trick I think. Have to stay on throttle to keep off the wall.


Have a crew member kick in the right place to create a vortex gap and Eraknoplan it?


Camber increases as the suspension compresses...


I for one am very excited about real life Tamiya car racing.


Ha ha, but seriously that wouldn't pass the pre-race template inspection.


But sirs, we like to travel with it on its side in the trailer so we can transport it more easily.


You could even put two little extra wheels on the door handles...


I know you're joking, but Nascar actually uses some cool tech [1] to make a 3D model of each car on-site to ensure they're in spec with regulations for size, aero, etc... Here [2] it is in action at the last Daytona 500

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-X_eujF8Z8 [1]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Laet8W8pn_k [2]


We mini 4WD now


one loose panel or an open exit gate or any other of little things and it would have been a serious accident


That was my first thought, but that whole wall should be able to sustain a full on impact from multiple cars in a wreck if there are loose panels or gates it is already a serious failure.

Not to say it couldn’t happen, just that it’s reasonable to assume the wall is designed to support more force than this.


THIS is the hacker mindset.


A special move being done in a crucial moment is interesting / amazing.

If it's too effective and everyone start doing it, it loses its charm.

Imagine if in Dota every game only consist of 3 tanks and 2 dps carries because it's too effective, it'll get boring soon.


Until someone gets hurt, this is kinda like a slapshot in hockey.

You can go to the inside, as is traditional, or you can go to the wall and risk it all...


Probably why they will soon make a rule against it :)


Probably need to change the wall as well


I scrolled all the way down, collapsing all the top level comments just to find your question, so thanks for posting it!!! This part of the discussion is what interests me the most.


He drove at full speed through a curve, letting him pass like 8 cars who were taking the turn normally.


He went faster through the curve and passed several drivers, to the point that he qualified for the next race when he otherwise wouldn't have.


he was significantly faster than the track lap record too


...which was set long time ago with significantly more powerful cars.


New lap record is 18.845 seconds. Old lap record was Joey Logano's 18.898 in 2014: https://joeylogano.com/logano-sets-track-record-starts-third...




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: