Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So now would be a good time to buy a PS5, keep it in boxed until this is released and use it to pirate all the games?


>now would be a good time to buy a PS5

This might be the bigger task than the actual jailbreak


My local Costco has had them for months. You have to buy it in a bundle with an extra controller and a game (and maybe a few other things), but it’s at MSRP for all those things.



Probably not - this exploit only works on firmware version 4.03. The latest being 6.0 which any new PS5 is likely to already have installed.


This exploit is only for 4.03, a pretty old firmware from December, most PS5 still unsold probably have way newer firmware.


Why don't you use the PS5 in the meantime, or wait with buying until later?


If you want to use it, the firmware will need to be updated, and therefore quickly no longer vulnerable once Sony patches it.

If you wait until later, the units in the shops will also have patched firmware.


It will likely get patched in following versions. Stores may be required to update the firmware before selling consoles.


On a sealed boxed console? No chance. It's literally the first thing that will pop up when a network connection is established.


Gaming is already one of the cheaper hobbies.

Going through the hassle of wasting time and nerves to pirate games that are very cheap to get after a few months after release or in sales is beyond my comprehension.


This is Hacker News after all. Tinkering with stuff like this has gotten people into soldering, emulation, PCB design, low level coding, etc., which then gets you into software/computer/electrical engineering.

It's not just about saving 50 bucks every now and then. At least for some, it's about satisfying intellectual curiosity as well.


A bit off topic, but I recently bought my first Xbox (series x) after owning every generation of PlayStation since launch. There were 3 reasons I opted for the Xbox: availability, aesthetics of the device itself (in my opinion the new PS5 is hideous), and most importantly Xbox Game Pass.

I am amazed at the number of high quality games on there for a relatively small monthly fee. Buying one new game at full price is the equivalent of around 6 months of game pass. So for the same price I can either have 2 new games a year, or have access to hundreds of games.

Subscription services like that make piracy completely redundant. Game pass is spotify for games, and I haven't bought or pirated music since I started using spotify


With an active life it took me more than two years to reach 140 hours of gameplay in horizon zero dawn. I have enough games to play until I am dead and beyond.


Game pass is nice if you aren't picky about what games you play. But if you feel like playing a game that's not on game pass, you are paying for nothing.


The biggest benefit to Game Pass that is seldom acknowledged is having the same game library for everyone. My friend and I can play together with hundred of titles to choose from, without having to convince one another to spend money.

We like this so much we sent an older Xbox One to a third friend with the idea to get him to buy Game Pass so we can all play together.

I dread the end of this early growth period for Game Pass.


Microsoft is much better about backwards compatibility and preservation than Sony, too. I have a library of Xbox and Xbox 360 discs I can just put in my Xbox Series X and still play, often with improvements. I can even still buy many titles from those generations digitally and play them on my Series X.

Meanwhile, Sony's missing many landmark titles from two generations, and your only option for playing PS3 games on a PS5 is streaming.


"I have a library of Xbox and Xbox 360 discs I can just put in my Xbox Series X and still play, often with improvements."

Not to take away from Microsoft's achievement (and commitment) here, but of course much of that is dependent on remote servers to supply the necessary patches, or in some cases going so far as to just treat the original disc as a DRM dongle that enables an entirely image to be downloaded.

This is backcompat that allows you to play titles from the last twenty years right now, and that's still a huge improvement over anything Sony or Nintendo have done in the last generation or so [1], and reflects the degree to which Microsoft sees that as a killer feature of Steam. But it's not super likely that this will still work in another twenty years— the only archival-quality solution is keeping the old hardware working or hoping for the best with emulation.

[1]: But do note that a Wii U can natively play Wii games, and can be jailbroken to natively play Gamecube games, since all three systems are iterations of the same underlying platform. The launch versions of Nintendo's handhelds always supported at least one prior generation of game card/cartridge as well. And of course the initial "fat" SKUs of PS2 and PS3 could both play the generation of games immediately prior— and none of this required internet access.


It wouldn't be the first time Microsoft takes over the world by providing a decent offering and excellent backward compatibility.


AFAIK you cannot even use an Xbox for the 1st time without connecting it to the internet. PS on the contrary you can pop a game and it runs offline. But it seems they have been working on removing these constrains which are truly crucial for preservation in the future.


Indeed... So many PS3 games I missed out on because of Sony's negligence. They used to be better. The PS2 included PS1 hardware inside it. Early versions of the PS3 included PS2 hardware.


Cramming a PS3 on the PS4 made no sense, unless you wanted a 599 dollars console vs a 399 dollars.

PS3 had a shaky launch precisely for that reason, it launched at 599. The PS4 launched at 399 (a hundred bucks cheaper than the Xbox One btw and one the reasons it got a massive lead since the beginning)


Then emulate it via software. There are open source PS3 emulators being developed right now. Why can't Sony use its billions of dollars to do it?


On the PS4 with those Jaguar cores it was simply not possible, maybe on the PS5?


A PS4 isn't fast enough to emulate a PS3.


Am still salty that the Sly Cooper HD trilogy for PS3 never made it to PS4.


That's a pure lie, look who ended their backward combability promise? your buddy Microsoft

https://geekculture.co/xbox-ends-backwards-compatibility/


Titles may suddenly disappear from your favorite libraries. This is usually because of license issues or removing online servers/services.


Buying on disc should prevent that.


Oh sweet summer child...


Yesterday I inserted a PS4 game disc in my PS5. First time for that particular title.

First thing it downloaded a 10 or 20 Gb patch...


Lol no ever disc games require patches these days.


Is there a documented instance of a game being removed from an account's library after being licensed via the online store?


All. The. Time.

Here is one website keeping track of it happening to various degrees: https://delistedgames.com/

Sometimes the game simply disappears from the store front but you can find it in your library. Sometimes it disappears from your library too, and you can request it via some process (https://delistedgames.com/get-your-games-back/). Sometimes you need to write the company in order to get a new key to whatever platform it is still available.

And sometimes it's just lost, with no recourse.


I looked at the games mentioned on the landing page and it's mostly online games whose servers are getting shut down. While that sucks and we should totally have the right to host our own servers without some asshole corporation C&Ding them, this isn't what I was talking about.

I have hundreds of video games. On steam I think it's over 200 titles. I can't tell if something I purchased ever disappeared from there. What I do know is I have lots of titles on my account that aren't sold on Steam anymore. Some GTA games with the original soundtrack, several EA titles that used to be sold on Steam once upon a time.

Is there a way to use this site to check my gaming accounts to see if I lost any games?


This is FUD, titles don't disappear from your Ps5 library when they get delisted.

If you buy a single player game digitally you should continue to have access to it for the life of the console as long as you aren't banned for doing something like disputing a credit card charge. (Which admittedly is a concern.)


Different provider (Steam) but related to your comment on disputing charges:

I returned a faulty game as is my legal right under UK law, Steam said they didn't allow that because they had their own much more restrictive rules. Eventually, I raised a PayPal dispute and PayPal choose to refund me (the amount was ~£1). They retaliated with restrictions to my account ... such restrictions as retaliation for fair exercise of rights granted by law is something that needs addressing.

I've noticed that game libraries, like Steam, now explicitly try to remove consumer rights with a click-thru pseudo-contract that directly contradicts UK law (roughly 'you give up rights to a refund'; whilst the Consumer Rights Act explicitly applies to digitally supplied goods).

Just thought this was a related point of note. Suppliers of intangible media have a little too much free rein.


There was a demo for a horror game called P.T. on PS4 made by Kojima. It got cancelled and the demo was eventually delisted from libraries preventing players from re-downloading it. The only way to play it is if you already downloaded it prior to delisting and never uninstall it. For a short while there was a way to download it via a web link, but Sony eventually shut that down.


Right, it was delisted but didn’t disappear from your library, exactly what the parent post said.


It did disappear from your library, it just wasn't auto-uninstalled from your system. But you can never ever download/install it again. That's why systems that have it installed already go for so much money on eBay.


You are technically correct but I did write "if you buy a single player game digitally..."

Nobody bought P.T.

The Scott Pilgrim game was delisted on the Ps3 when the license expired, and I can still download and play it today. Being delisted just means new customers can't buy it.

There's no way Sony's terms of service allow developers to pull games from the library after purchase, that would be a remarkable business failure on their part given how much leverage they have in negotiating the TOS with developers.


And when your CMOS battery dies after, hopefully, 20 years or so, the game will require a DRM check with Sony except it has been delisted


I just looked this up and the CMOS battery issue has been fixed for PS4 and Ps5 but not for Ps3. :(.


Do you have a source? I’m curious how they fix that, maybe they disable the DRM requirement?


I'm not on a computer where I can copy and paste a link. If you want a source type "ps4 cmos patch" in google.


You don't buy games you can only license them.


>Gaming is already one of the cheaper hobbies

I know there are cheaper alternatives, but gaming branded hardware is far from being cheap. Specially middle-high GPUs.

And for most people that want to upgrade their computers or a specific item, they prefer to buy something that will last at between 3 to 5 years.


If we’re talking about PCs you could buy an old office PC on eBay for $150 with a 7th gen Intel CPU and 16 GB of RAM and play a glut of low power games, retro emulators, etc. And if you’re willing to shell out another $150 for a 5 year old GPU you’ll be able to run just about any game, albeit on the lowest settings most of the time.


That's a very American view on prices. Multiply those by 10 for Brazil.

It's cheaper to fly to America and buy game consoles or PC hardware and fly back than it is to buy them in Brazil. Just be sure to hide your price tags from customs (or have a nice little bribe ready)


Just a decent set of tools for overhauling a bicycle cost me more than my Switch + games.


wait...

A stand, chain lube + cleaner, tubes+tube patch kit, chain brush, floor pump, chain drive tool, cable cutter and a set or two of wrenches/screwdrivers cost you more then a 200/300 euro switch plus at least one 60 euro game?

And you bought these? You didn't inherit all this stuff from your grandparents together with an "Oma fiets" or two when you born?

jokes aside, I do imagine that you might have more specialized tools. specially if you're working with some of the older sport bicycles that need love.


not really, e.g. music can be much cheaper to start (find an old guitar/digital keyboard) though get expensive if you want good instruments later on, i guess. sure ash cheaper than my shooting habit tho :)


I mean in this thread we are specifically talking about a £389.99 console (new) which has a huge subscription library at a fairly low price.

Sure, you can choose to buy a PC... but that's not a requirement (or indeed a preference) for lots of people in the hobby.


> Gaming is already one of the cheaper hobbies.

In the West maybe. To keep up with Playstation example, in my country you can buy 6 new PS5 games with the minimum salary.


Singapore is one of the richest countries in the world. Our minimum salary buys you exactly 0 PS5 games.

I'm not sure that says much either way.


can you elaborate a bit?

https://www.bal.com/bal-news/singapore-minimum-monthly-salar... says min salary is 3k sgd

https://store.playstation.com/en-sg/concept/10000956 says Gran Turismo is 98 SGD

so I am puzzled


The minimum salary is for foreigners on a work visa, not locals.


Yes. No minimum wage for locals.

Btw, Germany also didn't have a minimum wage until fairly recently.


I think the same now. But when I was a broke 15 year old I thought different. It was literally pirate or never play this game.


Have you never been a teenager without money ? Lucky you


Piracy isn’t a money issue, it’s a services issue.


True, to a degree. I won't ever pay 10-15€ for a 10 year old pc game but paying 1-3€ to have it in my steam library and not have to deal with wine/proton by hand is often worth it.


There is also an incredible variety of FREE indie games, standalone total conversion mods and whatnot.


It's not just that, it's to enable emulation. I'm not sure how pirated games would fare anyway in an online world nowadays, but getting emulators running is very interesting to me.


Oh, yes, but emulation is not piracy (at least in my view :-)


Allow me to make it comprehensible to you.

In Bolivia when I was teen, I loved to go to the markets and buy pirated PS2 games. Each one would be about 10 bolivianos. (Around $1.50 ish?)

Without these pirated games myself and all of my friends and people I knew would not have been able to play games period. Imagine buying a $60 + import tax for ONE GAME on a Bolivian salary? Ludicrous.

I'm very happy the PS5 will finally open and allow gamers in third world countries to play. The PS3 and PS4 to my knowledge never had that freedom the PS2 did back in the day.


How did you get a PS2 to play then?

Also note that there are thousands of games that are free to play on PCs. There are even lots of old commercial games that can be downloaded for free now, legally.

Just because you can't afford a particular game doesn't mean that there aren't other options. As a teen I couldn't afford every game I wanted either.


I got a PS2 as the big birthday present. Back then the free PC games were KNIGHT online, gunbound, Gunz online, Tibia.... slim pickings. Today kids have Fortnite and such, I agree.


It probably won’t or be locked to an specific version where only a subset of games will work, provided you never go online etc.


I'm scared to know what you may see as mid-budget hobby if you think gaming is cheap.


It is if you just don’t play current AAA games. I mainly do my gaming on a WiiU. Console and everything cost me $100 used. It plays pretty much every Nintendo game ever made short of the switch titles. Games are very cheap and of high quality.


A good table saw costs more than a gaming set up and it only does one thing. You will need more than one type of saw. You might need a planer, a drill press, a lathe. The list keeps getting bigger.

Or maybe you want to do machining(high end hobby), now you need a garage which will cost you ten thousands of dollars or you rent one for a hundred or maybe four hundred dollars per month. Then you need machines which cost more than 5k dollars and you guessed it, you will require multiple machines like that.


Getting a console for playing modern games on is a one time cost of $300 to $500. Such a console will be good for several years to come.

Getting free games per month or even getting access to a back catalogue of games with Game Pass or Playstation Plus is a monthly $9 to $15.

That's less than people pay that smoke.


Not to mention you can buy a PS3 or Xbox 360 for about $150 on eBay with a bundle that includes dozens of game discs. These consoles are over a decade old but they still hold up fantastically well.


SV developers might have slight trouble grasping that 4 hours of their work is someone's monthly salary.


Above all, gaming is one of the useless hobbies. I love it so much, yet it's giving so little to self-improvement...


Everything including reproduction is useless.

I don't know about you but I started programming because of Minecraft and learning about running a business by playing prosperous universe and this gave me some insights that make me suspect that money and it's non neutrality is the biggest unrecognised problem in economics. Remember economics 101 doesn't even have the concept of money or time. In fact econ 101 is an utopia that we want to reach, not how economics works in practice.

Positive reinforcement is worth more than people complaining that you are wasting your time by doing the wrong thing. People on HN say you should be curing cancer instead of building a factory in factorio. The former is a poorly defined multidimensional non linear search space with high chance of failure, the latter is a well studied problem with tutorials and guides. That is negative reinforcement.


Lots of hobbies are essentially "useless". The focus on being constantly "productive" seems toxic to me.

If you enjoy a hobby then it's not useless, enjoying it is the point of a hobby! So enjoy playing video games, growing houseplants, playing golf or whatever hobbies you have without feeling guilty about not producing as much as you could.


Eh, it depends. Every hobby has its benefits and its drawbacks.

I learned a ton of English, strategy, stress management, shortcut keys, programming and whatnot from games. Some games also took a lot of my sanity, sleep, relationships with living beings, etc. :)

Don't feel bad enjoying a hobby. The universe is your playground.


Maybe no shockingly obvious “improvements” but I’ve noticed friends and family who don’t game have a much harder time following the gps while the gamers usually have it on silent and glance every now and then with no issue. I bet there are a lot of mini things like that gaming improves.


I learned english and programming because of video games.


I don't know about useless, certainly keeps your mind and dexterity sharp.


I would’ve never learned to love computers if it were not for video games


Wait until you hear that some people don't even have indoor plumbing, 24h electricity and enough protein to eat, let alone extra income to waste on children's entertainment.


If you can find stock somewhere…


I suspect it depends on where you live - in the UK at least they're readily available in GAME for example.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: