Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Trying to solve objcopy's ugliness

Hey, I wrote objcopy and objdump as debugging tools for developing bfd targets when I was designing bfd. Neither was (originally) intended as a production tool. OK I still use them myself, and I haven’t looked at the bfd source code in almost 30 years.

I forget who came up with the tool chain target names, which I think was your real complaint, though I remember when. Perhaps Ian Taylor (later author of gold, which was notable for, among other things, not using bfd).

Objdump should have a feature to generate assembly or c code for an arbitrary blob (with correct byte swap, if needed, of course).




I always try to be respectful towards other software in my writing and I fell short this time. I hope you'll accept my sincere apologies!

> the tool chain target names, which I think was your real complaint

Yes, this was solely what I was referring to (slightly thoughtlessly) as "ugly", and even then only in the sense of "where did those magic names come from?" I certainly wasn't referring to objcopy itself!


don't worry: I'm not actually insulted. I just think it's funny that something intended for development debugging turn out to be actually useful (as I said I still use them too, and not for debugging bfd).


I've been using objcopy and objdump for a _long_ time. You saved my bacon on some really obscure archs (QCOM hexagon, for instance). Thanks!




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: