Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't think it's entirely clear that the US/Europe has the appetite to go to war over the use of a tactical nuke.



Has the US or NATO even threatened to go to war if Russia starts using tacnukes in Ukraine? I haven't seen any reports to suggest so, and I've been following the news on this war closely.

(The US has threatened more sanctions if Russia uses WMDs. That threat was in response to signs Russia was getting ready to use chemical weapons.)


Nuclear or chemical fallout that drifts into NATO countries could potentially warrant a response.

Here's one such article from a few weeks ago. https://www.military.com/daily-news/2022/03/23/if-russia-use...

Of course, we won't know for sure unless it happens (and let's hope it doesn't).


OK, but even when detonated high enough above the ground that no appreciable fallout is produced, nukes are quite destructive. In fact, for many kinds of targets, cities being one, the altitude that maximizes destruction is high enough.


My uneducated guess is that the primary goal of the latest rhetoric about the possible use of chemical weapons is intended to make this more clear. If "we" (not the US yet, but other countries that are nearer) are signalling a readyness to respond kinetically if chemicals are used, surely the message is that nuclear would trigger an even greater response.


Which military power has signaled a readiness to respond kinetically if chemicals are used?


The UK has stated that "all options are in the table" if there is a chemical attack. The implication to me is that a kinetic response would then be a possibility, since everything else is basically being done at this point..

Reference: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/ukraine-russi...


China might just drop their support of Russia if that happened.


If a tactical nuke is used, then it is proof that escalation to nuclear weapons does not imply the global nuclear holocaust that has been acting as a deterrent.

It eliminates the logic of not going to war.

Not that "logic" has any connection to "appetite" or that excuses require it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: