Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Some stats about the various ways of writing the project name (taken from these comments):

Fuchsia: 39

Fuschia: 19

Fushia: 1

Fuchia: 1

Other: ?

...so we can conclude that the UX of this codename is terrible. Maybe they should change it to something more easy to remember, e.g. Fuxia (Fucksya would probably also be easier to remember, but could be deemed too obscene)?



My conclusion from reading this is that Americans can't spell.


Then you can imagine how hard the name is for the other 7.5 billion people.


Is it? "Fuchsia" and derivatives are the names of a colour in romance languages - that covers a big chunk of that.


The colour is named after a plant, which looks down is named after a German chap called Fuchs.


I am Romanian and I have no trouble spelling and writing "Fuchsia".


It's still a situation with no clear solution.

Either it's a common word that is just hard to spell, and sticking to actual spelling is the saving grace as people who didn't know the spell will have a fighting chance to remember it.

Either they come up with an easier to spell version (e.g. "fuxia", but then those who knew the right spell will have to remember both, and those who "misspelled" the flower will be thinking Google's project name is the "correct" spelling.


There's still plenty of uncommon words that are easy to spell. "Anodyne" is a good example, it even sounds cool, but sadly means something not so cool.


> My conclusion from reading this is that Americans can't spell.

My conclusion from reading English all my life is that it’s a terrible unintuitive language and using the Latin alphabet for so many different-sounding languages wasn’t such a great idea.

Much like C++; taking the worst of all worlds.


Fuchsia is named after a German.


Sometimes discussions creep towards a superset of the context.


TL;DR: 'fuschia' actually works better with English spelling than 'fuchsia'.

English actually has a set of spelling rules that make it generally possible to predict the pronunciation of most words, while fuchsia is one of the words that sits well outside the spelling rules. The most notorious bits of spelling come when, as here, insistence is made on preserving the spelling despite sound changes making it completely untenable.

The original pronunciation of fuchsia in the German should be something along the lines of "fook-see-a". In English, the 'sia' would naturally want to affricate in that position (the same process that makes -tion pronounced 'shun'), which would lead to "fook-sha". I guess somewhere along the line, the k phoneme dropped, but the u also changes into an English long u (as in, it becomes the 'u' in 'cute' or 'cuticle').

The end result is that to spell the English pronunciation correctly, you need 'f', long 'u', something to spell 'sh' phoneme, vowel to make 'u' long (usually 'e', but 'i' can do the job in a pinch), and then 'a'. 'Fuschia' would be a spelling that comports with the expected pronunciation--while 'sch' is not the most common way of spelling 'sh', it is a way of doing so. And if you have only a vague of memory of what the word should look like, it has all of the requisite letters, and it yields the expected pronunciation--where the 'correct' spelling doesn't.

I'm generally a pretty good speller in English, and I will freely admit that the only way I can remember how to spell fuchsia correctly is that it's the spelling that fucks up--replace k with h.


Naming it "Fucksya" wouldn't be the best advertisement either


They’re being fearless about vendor lock-in!


The more popular it becomes, the more people will learn to correctly spell fooshia.


...I honestly propose a new "F*ks Yeah!" spelling for this project just to mindfuck with future programmer archaeologists


The name is perfectly fine from the perspective of a german-native speaker, just like the color Fuchsia.


...and no comments in here with either pink or Taligent?


To be fair, I didn't think anyone would be able to spell 'kubernetes' correctly. But life found a way - thank goodness for numeronyms!


A plant family named after a person called Fuchs.


A plant family named after a person called Fucks.


The Fuchs surname means "fox," from the Middle High German vuhs, meaning "fox."

Google makes a foxy OS. Shame it's not a fire-fuchs


In italian the color name is fuxia


The color's name is Fucsia, in Italian. Fuxia does not exist https://linguaegrammatica.com/fucsia-o-fuxia-come-scrivere


I think for a part you are correct, and for a part you are not correct, but if fuxia exist as a way to refer to the color in many places and/or instances, then Fuxia exists as a way to refer to the color and the fact that it does not exist is just theoretical https://www.google.com/search?q=fuxia&tbm=isch


True, but then again Italian has regular pronunciation rules and "x" is always pronounced the same way as "cs", so even if "fuxia" is not a proper spelling it's a homophone and I wouldn't be surprised to see somebody make that spelling mistake.


Not to mention the Fuchsia logo looks very much like the Fedora Linux logo.


Fewsha?


A useful mnemonic may be “Fuck Sia”, at least that was how I broke it down.


Watch you mouth young fellow!!! ;)

https://sia.tech




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: