Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"There are about 2.3 million third-party sellers on Amazon worldwide, according to information from a 2018 Amazon letter to its shareholders"

That number is pretty amazing. I never would've guessed over 2 million, and that number must be higher by now.




I would assume that the count includes the huge amount of people who sell cheap, unbranded Chinese products under a random all-caps name. So, not that surprising.


Why the all-caps brands for these? Is there some belief that it stands out more or something?

Because it does, and not in a good way. I skip all those when I'm browsing search results.


Many official looking order forms and paperwork in supply chains come filled out in all caps.

It's a descendant of all those forms you would fill in with pencil and they'd say "MUST HAVE CAPITAL LETTERS" for legibility.

I suspect that all those all caps descriptions come from when someone has quickly copied and pasted text from manifests and the like, directly into something customer facing.


These brands are often pad printed onto the products though (pointlessly, IMO), which is upstream of manifesting.


Not always. I've seen the name photoshopped on the listing photos and then be completely absent on the actual item.


> Why the all-caps brands for these? Is there some belief that it stands out more or something?

In some cases it may be the only thing the person knows how to do. When I texted something to the person who recorded my electricity meter in Shanghai, I got back the response "哈哈,THANKS".


They are most likely not switching language in their phone - you can see it with the full width punctuation. In Chinese mode, typing English is a little annoying to get case right. A lot of Chinese people don’t differentiate between case also.


To be totally fair, I have no memory of what kind of comma they used and the fullwidth one that I used represents an assumption by me. What stuck in my mind was the casing.

But other than that, yeah, I came to basically the same conclusion that you give here.


I’ve bought some of these all-caps items and some (probably over half) have been surprisingly good products. I’m not deciding between them and Apple usually, but between those brands on Amazon and the same products on Ali. Now that Ali shipping has been nerfed, I often buy from Amazon.


My general experience is these products are often 70-90% just as good for my needs, at like half the price.

I also get duds, which I return and 1 star.


I wonder if this includes inactive sellers.

In 2014/2015, I would buy insurance cargo from truck accidents: I had the space and the ability to grab and store the items until I could resell them via secondary means: This usually meant working with buyers at stores like BigLots and other discount stores, but, occasionally I'd get electronics (which isn't something that those stores really wanted).

I came across a huge lot of LG monitors that were involved in some fender-bender. Out of the lot of approximately 24 per pallet, only two were visibly damaged, and I had 12 pallets worth of monitors and the cost per-pound evened out to approximately $35/monitor.

I would sell these monitors, which were retailing for right around $200/each new, for approximately $150 in "Open Box" condition on Amazon, and would consistently sell anywhere between 8-10 of them a week.

Amazon charged me:

Cost for getting my items to Amazon (Usually around 9-11/each, depending on season and how busy UPS is), Cost for storing my item in their warehouse (usually around $2-4/month, depending on season), cost for picking and shipping my item (around $30 because it was considered oversize), and the constant reminder that these weren't my customers, they were amazon's customers (customers would "return" items, so, I'd get the entire cost of the item removed from my seller account, because, Amazon wouldn't eat their own fees here, and then have to fight them to get my money back when that customer wouldn't return the item). Amazon also fiercely competed with me on these monitors -- they'd knock down the cost of their "new" items down to what my refurbished cost would be...cutting me out of the 'buy box,' but, losing what I can only assume is about $30+ per monitor wasn't something that they did for long, as after a week or so, the price would be set back at MAP until I'd go and build a new shipment of items into Amazon, set a price lower than theirs, and then they'd automatically bring down their pricing to meet mine.

Amazon's profit to me would be around 40% -- around 80 dollars.

In 2016, Amazon changed the rules so I couldn't sell the items as "Open Box" and would have to sell them as "Used" because I didn't qualify under the rules as a refurbisher.

(admittedly, by that time, I transitioned away from selling items on Amazon and use a different channel for the sales of these items).

There are a lot of snake oil salesman selling "how to make money on FBA" videos and courses online, but, the reality is that the only entity who makes money selling new items on Amazon is Amazon.


Does that include everyone who has ever sold a used book on Amazon? Because I sold a few of my old college text books on Amazon about 20 years ago.


I would assume the number includes all unique seller accounts as it doesn’t specify a constraint on seller activity or similar.

In fact, (less reputable) data from marketplace research claims a far higher number in 2021 of over 6 million.

https://www.marketplacepulse.com/articles/amazon-reaches-six...




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: