Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's weird to imagine devious hidden motives like this, when recruiters already have obvious natural reasons to want to do a phone call.

Example 1: they need to get a rough idea of whether you're a jerk, whether you can communicate in the required language, whether your resume is BS, etc. Remember, nobody's paying the recruiter to find you a job - somebody's paying them to find high-quality candidates. Their job is to sell you, so naturally they want to know what they're selling.

Example 2: simple context switching. If your job required you to be involved in dozens or hundreds of simultaneous ongoing negotiations, wouldn't you find it more efficient to block out 30-minute calls with each stakeholder, rather than jumping around between a hundred different email threads full of single-question emails?

One could probably come up with more straightforward reasons. As a general rule though, nobody is ever consciously trying to waste your time. They're trying not to waste their own.



Another element to a phone call is commitment. If you are casually looking and only entertaining emails then you're probably not an active candidate and are a waste of their time. I don't even respond to recruiter emails anymore since I assume they are email bots.


Side discussion: Why is it that they have to find someone for the company? Why can't I instead have an agent that goes around and sells me to potential companies?

Right now recruiting is Yet Another Dysfunctional Industry with non-optimal behavior that favors job creation and useless busy-work instead of finding optimal solutions.


The value that recruiters offer is delivering good candidates. If you convince a recruiter that you're a good candidate, then they will run around selling you to companies! And companies will listen, because the recruiter has build a reputation by delivering good candidates in the past - that's how recruiting works.

But if you just pay an agent to run around selling you, there's no longer any value being added. Why would companies listen to a recruiter that just refers any old candidate that pays them?


I mean you could if you wanted. But why would you want to pay someone to line up interviews for you? Agents don’t get you jobs. They get you visibility.


In particular, scheduling over the phone avoids a lot of back-and-forth about which time works for whom.

There is also a legal concern - phone calls often times cannot be recorded so one can be more loose with their language.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: