> i have seen no-tip service implemented in a way that satisfied employees.
Have you seen no-tip service implemented with waitstaff earning as much as they did before?
> if tipped service was abolished tomorrow, employers would figure it out.
Of course they would figure it out if tipped service were abolished. But I am confident the outcome of whatever they figured out would result in lower take-home pay for waitstaff, as waitstaff would no longer be able to earn more money by switching to an establishment that allowed tips.
I don't doubt that equivalent compensation is necessary to get waitstaff to stay. I do doubt that it's possible for a restaurant to switch to no-tipping, offer equivalent compensation, and pay the kitchen staff more equitably.
Have you seen no-tip service implemented with waitstaff earning as much as they did before?
> if tipped service was abolished tomorrow, employers would figure it out.
Of course they would figure it out if tipped service were abolished. But I am confident the outcome of whatever they figured out would result in lower take-home pay for waitstaff, as waitstaff would no longer be able to earn more money by switching to an establishment that allowed tips.