Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> It would have been nice if the popular press had been a little more honest about the biology

You are not alone with this sentiment.

Some years ago, in my 20s/early 30s-something friend groups, any time the topic of declining female fertility with age came up, it was basically attacked as fake news and a conspiracy by older, conservative family members to get them to breed.

Moreover, sex education in school was 110% about all the wonderful ways you can avoid getting pregnant.

As I reflect back on it, no one calmly, but firmly gave the message that female fertility (in particular) is neither a given nor to be taken for granted, and that sooner than you expect it drops to zero. Beyond that point, it can only be extended by extremely expensive, painful medical procedures, and even then there is no guarantee.

----

Edit: Another thing that comes to mind is that women have it really tough, in a lot of ways, and this one feels the most relevant.

I think for women, people close to you and people who you don't even know seem to take particular interest in the choices you make with your body: How you dress, how you do your makeup, who you sleep with, who you date, what you do for work, etc etc etc. Infinitely more so than with men. I think with all that going on, for young women, discussions of female fertility just feel like yet another way people are sticking their noses in her business while telling her whats best and sapping her autonomy. And I think that's why to lots of friends groups with lots of 20-something women this all feels like fake news and sinister.



This is super unpopular, but I think young marriages actually give women more autonomy.

When you’re 18, marry a 30 year old guy — then take 6 years for undergrad, have three kids along the way, and let him pay for it. Then do graduate school while they grow up.

You’ll get out of school, debt free at 30, and already have three kids at school age — ready to be bussed off while you tackle that career. You won’t have to take a career break for children, because they’ll be in school when you start.


Raising 3 kids while at the same time completing undergrad studies in 6 years: I think you are missing some real-life experience to support that conjecture (I see you are adding 2 years on top of the standard 4 year undergrad program, so you are obviously trying).

I imagine you are not a mainly stay-at-home parent who did that, let alone one who went to University at the same time.

But even if you are, some kids are just that much harder to deal with than others (you know, just like some people are).

Now, my wife and I, who started having kids only in their 30s, admit that some of the things would have been much easier if we've only started earlier. But the likelihood of kicking off on a long, shared life path with someone you haven't met intimately, or without knowing yourself intimately (which I think is true for most people at 21, let alone 18), is minimal.


I’m not sure I agree, particularly with the last sentence — but I wanted to let you know I appreciate the thoughtful reply.

Have a good one!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: