Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There is an alternative. Go somewhere else if the cost of living in this society is too high.

Earning a tax free living clearly isn’t a right according to the U.S. Constitution. Go elsewhere if the cost is too high or advocate for lowering the cost. It’s a strange position to take that the benefits of the society you live in ought to be free to you when those benefits have costs.



> There is an alternative. Go somewhere else if the cost of living in this society is too high.

What if the cost of living is high somewhere else as well?

> Earning a tax free living clearly isn’t a right according to the U.S. Constitution.

The US Constitution recognizes rights, it doesn’t confer them or exhaustively catalog them.

> Go elsewhere if the cost is too high or advocate for lowering the cost.

This discussion could be an example.

> It’s a strange position to take that the benefits of the society you live ought to be free to you when those benefits have costs.

Its a strange position to be accused of wanting things for free when one identifies unnecessary waste.


If the cost of living in a different country is too high then I suppose you are destined to feel oppressed for the rest of your life. It’s a strange position to take. Given that very few people feel your way perhaps it is worthwhile to consider that your position is an extreme one and causing you unnecessary distress.

The Constitution gives government the power to tax. Therefore in this society earning a tax free income is not a right as far as this society is concerned. I apologize for not making that clearer.

The person I responded to did not claim there was unnecessary waste and thus taxes ought to be lower. Their position appears to be that the act of taxation is theft (since it’s done through violent means). Then you chimed in without stating that your position differs. You didn’t give any indication to having a different position to the person I responded to.

Thank you for the discussion. I will read and contemplate your response but will not respond further. It appears to me that we have irreconcilable differences of opinion on the matter.


There's a difference between pointing out government waste, wanting to lower taxes, wanting a smaller government, etc. and claiming that taxes are inherently violence, as the original post did.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: