Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I also hugely disliked the style and tone of the article. I finished it thinking "well, I guess anyone can call themselves a journalist nowadays". The humor was out of place too, just coming across as snobbish most of the time, even though I can tell what the author is doing. It's just....too much.

But hey, other people like it so who am I too judge ;-)



For me this had a David Sedaris, obsessive-compulsive writing style that I ended up hugely enjoying, though I admit I didn't get it at first and almost gave up reading. The fact that she opened a Freedom of Information request with the FDA about noodles while acknowledging that the agency was most likely preoccupied with the pandemic made me laugh out loud.

If this were just a matter-of-fact reportage on a particular type of pasta shortage I doubt it'd hold much interest for anyone. The whole enjoyment for me was the gonzo reporting style of someone going off the rails about the shortage of a particular type of noodle.


I don't normally comment on points count, but I've never had a comment go from +12 to 0 before, what a polarising opinion ;-)


Don't worry, you're not alone in thinking this article was trash, I stopped reading after the first paragraph




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: