Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Fundamental problem is also that many things in Indian legal system are done through criminal law, rather than civil law.

Also there is no codified torts, etc, causing people to seek remedies through criminal law and intimidation etc.




You can thank the Raj for that, for cognizable offences, for pre-arrest bail, for Section 144...


If independent India could send a space probe to the Moon, surely it could reform its legal system as well. Vast majority of Indians alive were born decades after the Raj ceased to exist.

Usually, when such old structures survive, it is because of concrete people and interest groups who want to keep them alive. And this is more of a domestic problem than a (ex-)colonial one.

In my country, compulsory identification cards were introduced by Nazis during the occupation. All subsequent regimes, including the democratic ones, kept them: too useful to scrap. But it would be misleading to say that we can "thank" Hitler for having cards in our pockets. We could have scrapped them if we wanted to, like we scrapped many other regulations and laws from that cursed era. We didn't.


For those who did not find it clear, the British Raj.

Same reason why Singapore has an anti-homosexuality law that is still propped up by Christian fanatics in govt.


> Also there is no codified torts, etc, causing people to seek remedies through criminal law and intimidation etc.

Won't tort legislation overwhelm India's already overburdened court system?




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: