Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin



To set the perspective for those not familiar, the population of the state is close to 900k, roughly the same as the city of San Francisco. The normal pace of all-cause deaths is about 24 per day, so with COVID-19 killing off 15 people per day it is probably the leading cause of death in that state today.


If I remember correctly, deaths today are linked with the hospitalizations 12 days prior.

From what I've seen, South Dakota is nearly out of ICU beds, as are many other states.

These Covid19 death rates are going to get really, really bad this time around.


Definitely. The die, as they say, is already cast. Remember, too, that the trailing 7-day average of an exponential process is incredibly misleading. If it's 15 deaths per day by that measure, that means it's really 50 today and 100+ soon.


Yeah, that graph added 7-day averaging because the reporting numbers bounce around on weekend boundaries, which was leading to a lot of confusion.

Whether there's 1-day or n-day averaging, exponential growth is the scary beast.


>From what I've seen, South Dakota is nearly out of ICU beds

Do you have a source for this?


According to the South Dakota Department of Health site, they 36.2% of the ICU beds are currently available [1]. According to this article [2], that count includes NICU (infant) beds, which will not be very helpful for COVID-19, which mostly seriously infects adults.

[1]: https://doh.sd.gov/news/Coronavirus.aspx

[2]: https://apnews.com/article/virus-outbreak-sioux-falls-voting...


How many beds are usually available? If there is, for example, only typically 40% of ICU beds available then being at 36% isn't that bad.


I've looked into these states and its really hard to get a good idea how close we are. There are easy solutions to quickly expanding ICU beds:

1) moving patients who don't need to be in ICU back to the regular wards. Hospitals tend to have a "use it or lose it" view of ICU beds.

2) you can turn regulars ward beds into ICU beds fairly quickly.

The limiting factor is essentially the doctors/nurses/staff. They are able to squeeze more space by forcing doctors/nurses/staff to work longer hours. But you can't shift radiology doctors/nurses to ICU since they aren't qualified.

We'll know things are bad when there is a call for doctors from less hard areas to fly to the infected areas.

Long story short, its hard to know as layperson what % is bad, so we should just listen to the experts.


I have wondered that myself, and it's a valid consideration.

Anecdotally, I've seen quite a few people who work in and around ERs and ICUs reporting a sharp increase in 'business', which follows (but trails) Covid19 positive test data.

We obviously don't know with any degree of precision how bad things are at the macro scale, but I think it's undeniable that the current trajectory is pretty scary.


I was looking at this site:

https://public.tableau.com/profile/todd.bellemare#!/vizhome/...

Noting that the adjacent comment also seems to have some good data.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: