I certainly get where you're coming from, and agree that all of the questions you listed are things we didn't express opinions on previously and had to decide for yourself.
Still, the bulk of the concerns I've seen over time fall into the categories I've listed - I just really don't remember seeing many comments from folks who were concerned that they "weren't using it effectively" as a particular pain point. Perhaps that was being felt, but expressed in different ways? (I definitely think a lot of people _haven't_ been using it effectively, but didn't necessarily realize it.)
In any case, the highly positive response to RTK and the docs work tells me we're headed in the right direction.
My next task is to rewrite the existing low-level "Basics/Advanced" tutorial sequence to remove outdated references, show simpler patterns, and improve explanations. I've got my notes on things I want to change here:
If you or anyone else has any particular feedback on things you don't like with that existing tutorial or would like to see covered better, please comment and let me know!
Still, the bulk of the concerns I've seen over time fall into the categories I've listed - I just really don't remember seeing many comments from folks who were concerned that they "weren't using it effectively" as a particular pain point. Perhaps that was being felt, but expressed in different ways? (I definitely think a lot of people _haven't_ been using it effectively, but didn't necessarily realize it.)
In any case, the highly positive response to RTK and the docs work tells me we're headed in the right direction.
My next task is to rewrite the existing low-level "Basics/Advanced" tutorial sequence to remove outdated references, show simpler patterns, and improve explanations. I've got my notes on things I want to change here:
https://github.com/reduxjs/redux/issues/3855
If you or anyone else has any particular feedback on things you don't like with that existing tutorial or would like to see covered better, please comment and let me know!