Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I guess I just don't think we should plan society around the assumption that the internet will overreact and take justice into its own hands, which is not in fact justice. Why can't we hold people on the internet accountable for harassment?



That is an orthogonal concern. We should hold people accountable harassment. But I don't see the need to put someone in a position where they are likely to be harassed. The upsides of putting someones name out there seem tiny and the downsides are obvious, so why do it?


because you put ppl at risk without any benefit. you could easily as said I believe I know who did this and I've turned that information over to the authorities.

what does the public or kerp gain by putting it out in public when you dont know.

yes he (kerp) can be held accountable (and should be hit immediately with a defamation lawsuit if hes wrong) but not everyone has the resources to do that.

look at reddit and boston bomber the person they accused killed himself..


> look at reddit and boston bomber the person they accused killed himself..

Do we know this was due to the Reddit misidentification? His body was found on April 23, after being accused on April 18, but he had been missing since March 16. I've never seen a definitive order of events given.

(I've no doubt such accusations _could_ lead to such horrible outcomes, but I'm not sure if we know they did here with certainty)




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: