Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You’re talking about human beings who are responsible for their own actions.


And yet people generalize the action of a few to the whole protest.


Yes, especially when they say things like, "If you see the community, or the people, as a single organism..."


it's like you're actively trying not to understand my comment?


Not at all. If looting and vandalism is “the action of a few”, then it doesn’t make sense to characterize it as “self-defense” on behalf of some collective “organism”. It’s like you switched sides and started arguing my point in the middle of the argument.


> If looting and vandalism is “the action of a few”, then it doesn’t make sense to characterize it as “self-defense” on behalf of some collective “organism”.

Then we'll have to agree to disagree, opportunists don't exist without a crowd.


What is the point of your comments? You mention the community as an organism that can't control where the harm is directed, that is acting in self-defense. But the people looting, breaking windows and throwing stones are individuals that chose to participate in violent riots. They are not acting in self-defense.


The point of my comment is that you will always have bad apples, doesn't make the whole field rotten.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: