Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Why not use Teams Live for this? We have been using zoom and Teams alternately and Teams performance and ease of use has been much better in my experience, but we have yet to do a 200+ all hands so I was curious if there were some footguns with teams live that you may know about. Teams live works on a lot of platforms and also has a web version.



Why not use Teams Live for this?

My wife was on a Teams videoconference last week. 125 people in four locations from New York to Southern California.

An hour into it, half of the people were simultaneously dropped, and not from any particular geography. It was random. And nobody could reconnect for a very long time. It took 45 minutes to restart the meeting.

The company is no longer using Teams.


have only recently started using teams with one client. small group (max 6 folks I think) and... we've had issues with it - someone's video freezing, audio garbled/dropping, etc - twice in 2 days. but... I'm sort of chalking it up to potentially overloaded/bad net connections in the wake of all the WFH and remote meeting stuff being used. We had issues with connecting to zoom (and their phone numbers) last week as well, so I'm not ready to pull the plug on teams entirely until we have more experience under our belts.


To be fair I’ve seen the same thing happen with Zoom. During a 2 hour meeting with a client, about half of my team was dropped and couldn’t get back into the meeting for several minutes.


Teams live events (https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoftteams/teams-live-e...) which the parent comment was refering to is actually a specific feature in Teams that is only available for certain levels AFAIK but supports vastly more people than a standard Teams meeting.


The predecessor, Skype Broadcast allowed completely anonymous viewing, basically a twitch or youtube stream. In the name of growth hacking, the Teams team decided to force people to the app, you couldnt watch the video stream from a mobile device without the teams app. Which is a huge amount of friction for a mobile workforce that isnt using teams.

Maybe this has changed since I last talked to Microsoft, but even their own team was unhappy with it. But if you still have access to broadcast.skype.com, it still works, until they decide it shouldnt.


The only Teams Live meeting I've ever tried to join, we had two people who gave up because their web version didn't support Safari without having to manually go deep into their preferences and change settings from the default.


I don't know of any, but our teams uses Slack, not Teams. Barely any complaints about Slack video chat btw, but that's all small sessions anyways.


My employer has used Teams Live for all-hands meetings from home the last couple weeks and it worked great for ~350 attendees.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: