Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

how should you know that the voltage regulator doesn't have internal caps without seeing the specs?

Can you name one voltage regulator that has them? Maybe you've worked with a few, but just off the top of my head, the 78xx, 317, and 1117 don't, and neither do all the other miscellaneous ones that I've seen in consumer electronics.



Traco Power has some. I don't know which one we used on the top of my head but kinda like this with fewer pins: https://www.tracopower.com/products/browse-by-category/find/...

It's not my field and I had little clue what was happening at the EE level. Maybe you could argue they are not what is normally meant by saying voltage regulators.


That's a module, not a chip. If it's one of those 1mm x 2mm sot packages, it almost certainly doesn't have embedded switching capacitors.


Integrated Switched-Capacitor Voltage Regulators will definitely be a thing in a few years they have already been produced in research labs and quite likely reached even limited production for low power <10W applications.

In general I agree with the GP look at how many unpopulated areas exist on modern boards.

How should you know if the lack of input filtering is because of poor design vs the fact that the spec of the power supply changed and you no longer need it?

If it’s not universally true and obvious it’s not a good test.

Modern boards are super complex I’m not an EE but I would more likely flag lacking probe points, probe points which are too far or too close apart or too far from common ground as bad design choices than try to figure out if there are enough caps for the voltage regulator without knowing the full specs of the damn thing.

For all i know that voltage regulator isn’t even being used anymore because the IC or PSU specs have changed mid production but because it was wave soldered with a different soldering method than the other SMTs they already had them on a bunch of boards...

If you can’t reverse engineer the board or the relevant within a few min it shouldn’t be in an interview.

Not an EE but I do a lot of HW RE if anyone puts a modern multi layer doubled sided board on my lap and tells me to point out what’s wrong with it in an interview I would ask them what’s wrong with them.


78xx/79xx don't need caps for stability either, according to their datasheets. Still seems a bit janky to leave them out.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: