> but certainly not on big bill items such as housing and education
On average, housing expenditures only makes up about 25% of American household income. And education expenditures are nearly a rounding error at 1.8%.
Adjusted for inflation the median cost per square foot of a new home in the US actually fell by 8% from 1992 to 2018. It's true that Americans are spending more on housing than in the past, but that's mostly because they're buying significantly bigger houses.
The median new home saw its square footage increase by more than 50% since 1985. Despite a decline in the average household size. And that doesn't even cover the significant increase in quality in things like central AC, attached garages, fire safety, higher ceilings, high ampere electrical circuits, better insulation, etc.
The HN community is biased on this topic because they tend to live in HCoL metros like the Bay Area and to only recently be out of school.
But the fact of the matter is that the vast majority of middle America in flyover states has not seen any significant loss of affordability in housing. That should tell you that the problem isn't globalization, it's the San Francisco zoning board.
> Overall an American worker who lost his well paying manufacturing job and replaced it with a job at walmart lost massively.
Since 1980 the decline in manufacturing employment have been more than offset by growth in high-paying jobs in healthcare, education, professional services, real estate, and financial services.
American manufacturing output is at an all-time. There's huge job shortages in the industry, and American factories are desperate for workers. That should tell you that manufacturing jobs were never "replaced", rather Americans workers decided to move to other industries.
Manufacturing jobs are good-paying, but dangerous, physically demanding and unpleasant. Most workers who left decided to either go to skilled construction trades or natural resource extraction, where pay is significantly better. Or they decided to become skilled professionals like nurses, teachers, or realtors, where pay is still good but working conditions are significantly better.
On average, housing expenditures only makes up about 25% of American household income. And education expenditures are nearly a rounding error at 1.8%.
Adjusted for inflation the median cost per square foot of a new home in the US actually fell by 8% from 1992 to 2018. It's true that Americans are spending more on housing than in the past, but that's mostly because they're buying significantly bigger houses.
The median new home saw its square footage increase by more than 50% since 1985. Despite a decline in the average household size. And that doesn't even cover the significant increase in quality in things like central AC, attached garages, fire safety, higher ceilings, high ampere electrical circuits, better insulation, etc.
The HN community is biased on this topic because they tend to live in HCoL metros like the Bay Area and to only recently be out of school.
But the fact of the matter is that the vast majority of middle America in flyover states has not seen any significant loss of affordability in housing. That should tell you that the problem isn't globalization, it's the San Francisco zoning board.
> Overall an American worker who lost his well paying manufacturing job and replaced it with a job at walmart lost massively.
Since 1980 the decline in manufacturing employment have been more than offset by growth in high-paying jobs in healthcare, education, professional services, real estate, and financial services.
American manufacturing output is at an all-time. There's huge job shortages in the industry, and American factories are desperate for workers. That should tell you that manufacturing jobs were never "replaced", rather Americans workers decided to move to other industries.
Manufacturing jobs are good-paying, but dangerous, physically demanding and unpleasant. Most workers who left decided to either go to skilled construction trades or natural resource extraction, where pay is significantly better. Or they decided to become skilled professionals like nurses, teachers, or realtors, where pay is still good but working conditions are significantly better.
[0] https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cesan.nr0.htm [1] https://www.census.gov/construction/chars/ [2] https://www.census.gov/const/C25Ann/sftotalmedavgsqft.pdf [3] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/03/job-gains-for-the-manufactur... [4] https://www.reliableplant.com/Read/30044/manufacturing-worke... [5] https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2016/article/current-employment...