Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You roll your lower lip over your bottom front teeth, bring the container to your mouth, and pour the liquid into your mouth while gently resting the lip of the container on your lip.


Girls need straws for lipstick, guys need straws for beards, elderly need straws for health concerns.

They aren't "completely superfluous".


People don't need lipstick, lickstick is superfluous.

I've never needed a straw while drinking and I facial hair, but I guess personal anecdotes are useless, and cleaning your face occasionally with a napkin(or a sleeve) is... forbidden?

As for the elderly, if your health requires you to use a straw why are you relying on someone else to meet your needs? You should provide your own straws if drinking without a straw is a health concern, right? Someone with a peanut allergy shouldn't rely on the restaurant to have an epi-pin.


Agree, with enough dedication we can remove our reliance on anything. Coffee, tv, internet, phones, straws, bananas...

Still doesn't mean it is a good idea or that it will solve anything.

More in specific, we can remove straws from our life (you can also claim that all the noise about it raised public awareness), but when Starbucks solution is to use even more plastic in their lids, McDonald's solution are paper straws that cannot be recicled and raise a huge controversy for focusing on something silly I am not sure it was a net ecological win.


Single use lids are next.

We're destroying the environment because we can't be assed to take a break to have a drink.


We are not "destroying the environment" and you are not going to "save the environment".

This is childish. Nations which don't have good sanitation systems are dumping garbage into the oceans, as are ships. Your attempt to self-flagellate, or more accurately flagellate others by abstaining from straws does not help or hurt the environment. It does annoy people and cause resentment and blowback that might stop useful engineering solutions, though. It's a type of modern religious ritual meant to absolve yourself of invented sins because you think you have something to do with plastic in the oceans when the real culprits are thousands of miles away.

If you want to clean up the oceans, try to find a way to provide asian and african nations with secure sanitation systems, and to improve the sanitation handling on ships. Container ships are quite dirty also because of the sulfur being burned. Lots of potential solutions that don't have anything to do with personal abnegation -- it may not feel as good, but for that you should go to church or synagogue rather than trying to invent your own eco-shamanism. The environment is improved by engineering solutions and development in the third world, not by acts of personal purity in the wealthy west.


> It's a type of modern religious ritual meant to absolve yourself of invented sins...

Nail on the head.


Most people don't need them.

Some people are switching to metal straws, while some restaurants are using dry pasta straws (the pasta doesn't go soft as the drinks are cold).

There are alternatives for those that need them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: