Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Shadowbanning didn't originate at Reddit either, it's been a feature of online forums since at least the 90s.



No of course it didn't. I'm just saying I think Facebook implemented it after we told them about it on reddit. It wasn't something they had thought of before that. We did it on reddit without knowledge of the other cases too. It's a pretty obvious solution honestly.


That seems unlikely, shadow banning has been around for a long long time.


I think he's saying that as far as Facebook goes, they for sure knew in 2012, so they can't plead ignorance or convergent evolution.


Well he said he knew that they took the idea from Reddit, that's the part that seems unlikely.


> and they hadn't considered it before that. I'm pretty sure reddit is where they got the idea...

pretty sure implies he has a hunch that they did, not 100% certainty. They may've said they hadn't considered such a thing before in a "forum" that the OP was able to overhear this either directly or indirectly and it wouldn't be a stretch to consider that in Facebook's history of borrowing from others, they then borrowed it from reddit.

It doesn't discount that it existed prior to reddit, just that they may have been the source for Facebook.

Microsoft was selling Office 365 subscriptions for a while and I never bought one. Eventually, I bought one from Amazon. So it is both true that I got it from Amazon, but that Microsoft had them prior.


This! We were shadowbanning people on IRC in like 2001. Unreal IRCd had a shadowban plugin that literally did exactly what modern shadowban features do.


I remember /shun.


I don't suppose the term "Asgard" means anything of significance to you, does it?


Greybeard BB Golden Rule: If Techy doesn't play nice, Techy goes to Coventry


I remember it from the old bulletin boards on Freenet since at least '94.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: