Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

BoJ's money printing is dwarfed by Fed's and ECB's money printing. Japan has been doing it since 1989, Softbank cant be explained by Japan alone.

> Zero or even negative interest rates will distort valuations and capital allocation.

interest rates policy ( monetary ) has little to do with capital efficiency.

Central banks have rightly figured out a few things :

- Their respective countries have taken on too much debt, and we need to do something to reduce it.

- Market forces ( globalization + technology ) are having tremendous deflationary effects that is pushing down interest rates, their job is to find out that number.




> BoJ's money printing is dwarfed by Fed's and ECB's money printing. Japan has been doing it since 1989, Softbank cant be explained by Japan alone.

BoJ's money printing is on the same level as ECB and Fed. Most recent data I could find is here: https://www.valuewalk.com/2019/05/gundlach-g4-central-banks-... Both ECB and BoJ hold around $5trn in assets, Fed is third with around $4trn.

> interest rates policy ( monetary ) has little to do with capital efficiency.

I don't know what you mean by capital efficiency. The BoJ corporate bond purchasing program lowers interest rates for all issuers on the Yen bond market, including the ones issued by SoftBank. Because SoftBank itself invests into the fund (around $28bn) and raised capital with bond issuance the link between BoJ open market interventions and startup valuations should be clear.

> Central banks have rightly figured out a few things :

> Their respective countries have taken on too much debt, and we need to do something to reduce it.

In the case of the ECB and the Fed (don't know about BoJ) the reason is actually the opposite. Fiscal expansion has been very unpopular politically in both the US and the EU (there mainly due to the fiscal austerity demanded by Germany). Because there was no political will to increase national debts, the central banks stepped in and started to directly purchase bonds (both governmental and private) in order to rekindle growth after the financial crisis. If governments started massive infrastructure projects or otherwise expanded their balance sheets, then this central bank intervention would have been much smaller. As a result of central bank interventions - which has reduced interest rates for gov. bonds - countries have started to issue more debt once again.

> Market forces ( globalization + technology ) are having tremendous deflationary effects that is pushing down interest rates, their job is to find out that number.

As far as I know there isn't a consensus for an explanation why the current low inflation environment persists (the "New Normal"). Globalization and technology might well be an explanation but global demographic shifts could also be an important factor (ageing populations and declining birth rates in most industrialized countries).


Here is a much better graph showing the same data:

https://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user330...

You are right, since 2013 BoJ has bee busy with the printing press.

> I don't know what you mean by capital efficiency. The BoJ corporate bond purchasing program lowers interest rates for all issuers on the Yen bond market, including the ones issued by SoftBank. Because SoftBank itself invests into the fund (around $28bn) and raised capital with bond issuance the link between BoJ open market interventions and startup valuations should be clear.

Soft Bank has assets that allows them to borrow, if Soft Bank didn't exist, somebody else would have taken advantage of the lower interest rate.

My point is that even when a lot of money is printed, capital goes to who is able to convince the bank the most. BoJ, Fed does not have much control in where the money is allocated.

> ... Because there was no political will to increase national debts, the central banks stepped in and started to directly purchase bonds ...

The problem here is that those bonds were about to lose a large amount of its value - as private debt repayment was not possible. So yes, private debt was high. CB's had no choice but to buy them , or else face a severe contraction in the money supply.


country debt is a non-issue. It's private debt that you have to worry about.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: