Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You're saying that using Newpipe to download a video doesn't break YouTube's TOS?


I don't know about Youtube's TOS, but Newpipe in it's github repo says that the app violates playstore TOS.


IIRC it is because Play Store terms of service are incompatible with the GPL license.


There are plenty of GPL apps on the play store. There was some drama over vlc in the apple store due to GPL concerns, but I don't remember if there was real merit to that. In any case, newpipe's issue is different. For one, it doesn't show ads. So that would disqualify it from playstore anyway. Playstore is google's walled garden afterall. That doesn't mean that newpipe is doing something illegal.


You do not download videos under standard license, only download videos under CC-BY-SA (which do have download button on the web).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: