Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

| Often when your body feels "hungry," it is actually thirsty for water.

Complete bullshit. Penn and Teller killed this one pretty convincingly.

Basically, if you eat a 'normal' diet (which most people don't, ironically) including enough veggies and fruits, there's no real need for outside water sources.

For most people, enough water that you don't feel thirsty is sufficient. There's no need to force yourself to drink water. And hungry very, very rarely means thirsty.




Thanks for the reply. First of all, I would not take dietary advice from Penn and Teller, just by using common sense and looking at Penn. But, on top of that, you went out of your way to call what I said "bullshit", basing your belief on what a magician said in a TV show by the same name, without ever quoting what the magician actually said.

Also, you claim that people very, very rarely feel hungry when they want water.

It's easy to show you're just guessing. Have you ever eaten a solid meal without drinking fluids? Then how can you be sure that the hunger you felt was just for food, and liquids only to wash it down, instead of hunger for water as well? You can't. It could very well be correlation, and not causation, that when you eat, you want to drink water as well, which means that you were hungry for water all along.

If it's even 1% hunger for water, that proves you are wrong.

Also, there's no such thing as a normal diet.


I'm not citing Penn, per se. He interviewed several doctors and nutritionists, they were the ones who stated that additional water in the diet is largely unneeded, and that rumors of chronic dehydration in the general populace are wrong.

Also, Snopes has addressed the topic: http://snopes.com/medical/myths/8glasses.asp

Believe what you'd like, but don't try to mislead other people with it.

(Have I ever eaten a solid meal without drinking fluids? fuck yes. are you kidding?)




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: