Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What conclusions can be drawn from this? If any?


Not many. I read that Vue is popular in China.

From a comment on Reddit:

> 1.6 million weekly downloads for React vs. 200k weekly downloads for Vue. I don't think the GitHub stars measure much. People are downloading react at approximately 8 times the rate of vue.

* https://www.npmjs.com/package/react

* https://www.npmjs.com/package/vue


Something to note though: This doesn't count the mirror registries in China. Also Vue devs may be more likely to use CDN links.

(I would still bet that React is used much more yet, just noting that the NPM comparison doesn't tell the whole story - nor does the stars comparison)


How many are for udemy related tutorials verus new projects? I bet the numbers are closer.


If X is the number of times that a Github repo star button has been clicked, minus the times that it has been un-clicked, then as of today X_vuejs > X_reactjs.

I'd be curious of what other metrics Github stars correlates with (# of applications in production, $ in revenue/investment, etc.), but I suppose if Vue ends up replacing React in clear popularity that some will point to this as a significant moment in that history.


1. People over-index on pointless measures.


JS ecosystem's trends are as stable and predictable as English weather.


That's a bit of an outdated meme.

There are lots of micro libraries because there's zero barrier to putting something on github and NPM, and there's a huge population of people wanting to practice and demonstrate their programming skill.

Many of those are irrelevant. Guess what? Me throwing a "cool-cucumber.js" library doesn't obligate anyone to learn or keep up with it.

It's like a random author publishing a random book. Who cares? you don't have to read it.

The rest is much more stable. There's a bit of fluff on the surface but underneath is not changing that much.


People fear things outside their comfort zone, and resist understanding them.

My father is afraid of git. My sister in law is afraid of open source software. And, that fear is reflected in their career choices and the quality of their code.


FUD; what major upheaval has been in the field since idk, Vue was released?


Major upheaval? I think big dotcoms efforts to forcefully push their vapourwares onto the dev community in attempt to gain developers' "mindshare" reaching a point when that becomes genuinely obnoxious.


Angular and React are getting bloated.

Vue is still one of the few frameworks that stays lean.

Easier learning curve by new developers trying to pick a front end framework.


Angular has always been bloated, but, how has React gotten bloated? Do explain.


I was also surprised by that comment. I just checked and React still has on the order of less than 30 methods/properties in its entire public API surface. Vue.js has quite a bit more.

If the parent means by byte count, React + ReactDOM is about 32.5KB, Vue is 30.3KB. Not a dramatic difference in byte bloat, either.


It's the ecosystem that makes it seem bloated. 32k vs 30k is nothing.


Wait, what? A large ecosystem of libraries that are not included by default but are available for you to use is somehow a bad thing (as "bloat" implies)?


I agree with you, but there's a joke about npm and leftpad in here somewhere.


Every new developer I know is picking React because that's what the jobs want.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: