Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Could you please name those communist countries?

I still have family in mainland China, and we know there is a homelessness problem in China. The government effectively insures that they are out of sight, so they beg where they can out of sight. You can find them in loading docks or behind restaurants. This is not a new problem that has started since economic reforms, it has always been around.

I have talked with my coworker, someone who lived in Soviet Russia until his 20s, and he will confirm that they also had homelessness problem. At that time it was dealt with similarly.

(1)Simple searches give clear depictions and discussions of the homelessness problems in these current and historical examples.

(1)Post edited here to remove an inappropriately rude and confrontation postscript (I accused the parent of lying or being willfully ignorant; which does not cover the gamut of possibilities)




I've lived in Poland, spent plenty of time in then Czecho-Slowakia and a lot less in Eastern Germany.

> You are either dramatically incorrect or lying.

Sorry ?


You begin the post with "He's right though," and then provide anecdotal evidence. I am not arguing against your experience. Your experience is not wrong; I am arguing against that the grandfather post is "right" that homelessness is a symptom of capitalism, to which you agreed and supported.


Those countries that did not have homelessness under Communism have plenty of it under capitalism, for those countries that I have experience with.

That's not a scientific study, but it definitely should give you pause. Oh and I forgot to add Romania to the list.

I said "in the communist countries that I've visited", to qualify my experience, and to make sure that you understood that I was not speaking for all communist countries at all times.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: