Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Right, the source isn't important. What matters is whether what you've received is, for practical purposes, actually currency.

If your boss showed up and said "from today we're going to pay you in bananas, and our exchange rate is $1000 per banana. By the way here's a raise too" and drops a bundle of bananas on your desk... Would you consider yourself paid?

Bananas aren't even fiat! You gotta grow them first

This is a silly example, since in the article there's clearly consent on both sides of the equation. But if the coins remain as "e-points" in their system and there's not much incentive on the buy side, they're not super useful as currency.

In practice the crypto currency markets seem to fuel a good amount of liquidity. This is a pretty neat side effect of the block chain boom.



> our exchange rate is $1000 per banana

This implies that your boss is ready to trade both ways. I'd gladly accept the bundle of bananas.


> This implies that your boss is ready to trade both ways.

Again, this is the definition of currency. The root comes from Latin and means to "flow" or "run." It's this condition of "flowing" that defines currency. As I said before, this shared perspective of how well a currency "flows" is what defines it's value. Fiat or otherwise doesn't matter. In the strawman presented here, you (and maybe the rest of the company) accept and will participate in the exchange rate, so bananas have become a slightly stronger currency. For most of the world, it's still pretty terrible, but they are marginally better because at least some people accept it as currency.

Unless we plan to go back to bartering, this same logic applies for all forms of currency. There's nothing special about gold, bitcoins, rectangular plastic cards, or green sheets of paper with dead people's faces printed on them. What gives these things value is simply society's willingness to use these as a means of conducting transactions.


I would _mostly_ agree, but gold is actually a bad example as it has quite a bit on intrinsic value due to it's interesting metallurgical and electrical properties.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: