Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'm a strong second amendment supporter but I will probably never own a gun. I know accidents happen, and an accident with a gun scares the shit out of me. I have kids, and the risk is too great.



You don't have a pool do you?


Once the kid learns to swim you're done.But there is no way to teach a kid tonot to die from a random bullet.


Because people who know how to swim don't drown? Like, ever?


> But there is no way to teach a kid tonot to die from a random bullet.

How is basic/safe operation, safe handling procedures (call an adult!) not effective teaching?


I've known many casesof guns accidentally firing when being cleaned and causing deaths. Usually a child or a spouse.


You hear accidents happening to people with thousands of hours handling weapons. No mistakes on their part, just the gun going off. I can't risk the biscuit.


Modern factory firearms quite simply do not go off accidentally. With extremely rare ecxeptions, "cleaning accidents" are either failed suicide attempts or extremely negligent mishandling.

Look up the four main rules of firearm safety. Adherence to these rules will all but eliminate the risk of a dangerous malfunction (extremely rare) or fumble (less rare) during firearm operation and cleaning.


> With extremely rare ecxeptions, "cleaning accidents" are either failed suicide attempts or extremely negligent mishandling.

Nope, they happen. I'll leave it to you to search for them. For me, there are people who need guns, and people who must not have them. They're killing machines and serve no other purpose (unlike the knife which has utility).


Not to be dismissive, but it's very clear you don't know what you're talking about here. Fundamentally, to put oneself in a situation where an accidental discharge (operator-caused or not) poses a health risk, you've already violated several fundamental rules of gun safety. So these things fall very squarely into the realm of "negligent mishandling". I can think of very few scenarios where I would attribute a "cleaning accident" to the gun, as opposed to an ignorant operator.

As for the rest of your comment, that line of reasoning has been addressed thousands of times, so I won't bother being thousands plus one. My firearm usage doesn't involve killing anything, so this should be a big glaring hint that there's an error in your reasoning.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: