Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Are they going to block admin Windows accounts too?



Why would they....

ohh you believe if you are an "Admin" on windows you have control over the OS.... no Redmond has control over the Windows OS, they have DRM built in well below "Admin"


Ok, let's put it this way: Are they going to block root Linux accounts too?


Well

1. Root on Linux is not the same as Admin on Windows. Sorry

2. They do limit Linux playback to 720p, you can not play 1080p or higher streams on linux largely due not having control over the OS.


> 1. Root on Linux is not the same as Admin on Windows. Sorry

No need to be sorry, but how so?

> 2. They do limit Linux playback to 720p, you can not play 1080p or higher streams on linux largely due not having control over the OS.

I didn't know that. Is it done based on OS detection or is it just Netflix neglecting to support? What if I fool Netflix into thinking I'm running windows? Will I be able to play 1080p/4k then?


>No need to be sorry, but how so?

With root on linux there is nothing outside of your control, With Admin on Windows there are still all kinds of things outside of your control. Just look at the Telemetry controversy as an example. No way for even an "admin" to disable it

>I didn't know that. Is it done based on OS detection or is it just Netflix neglecting to support?

In order to play HD Content you much have a OS that refuses to follow the Admin's wishes, instead follows the wishes of the OS Vendor.

You much have full stack DRM built into the OS that is not bypassable.

Currently the Only OS that support browser based HD Playback from netflix is Windows in the Edge Browser because MS DRM is built into the OS and the Admin of the OS has no control over it.


> What if I fool Netflix into thinking I'm running windows? Will I be able to play 1080p/4k then?

Not without SilverLight or their app as far as I can tell.


Has the reason for the 720p cap been confirmed anywhere? All I'm getting from the helpdesk is that it is browser limitation, not policy. Is there something in the HTML5 DRM standard that imposes this limit?


https://help.netflix.com/en/node/23742

Resolution:

  Google Chrome up to 720p

    Internet Explorer up to 1080p

    Microsoft Edge up to 4K*

    Mozilla Firefox up to 720p

    Opera up to 720p

    Safari up to 1080p on Mac OS X 10.10.3 or later
Mainly it has to do with PlayReady / Widevine support at the OS Level. Windows has PlayReady baked into the OS, and will communicate with the Edge Browser in a Secure way that can not be bypassed by any user on the System

Linux and other browsers on Windows lack the ability to do this at an OS Level there for netflix limits the stream quality because the OS does not have the proper DRM Controls

This is the exact same reason they do not want the Netlfix app on Rooted devices


> They do limit Linux playback to 720p

Joke's on them. I only use Netflix on my laptop on the go and then my bandwidth is usually bad enough that 1080p is unachievable anyway.


Thats called windows 10 s




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: