Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Im not sure we can fully disentangle the wave-equation for the photon from the equations for the splitters

That doesn't matter. The two sides of the experiment are space-like separated, and the splitters on each side are light-like separated. There is no place the information can possibly be other than in the photons.



...except non-local variables. Which is why I keep mentioning non-locality.

I don't think words are working and I'm not sure I understand your point fully. Could you draw a diagram? Specifically, the apparatus and where you think the requirement for information occurs.

I really do want to understand your point, because it's an interesting argument, even if I'm not sure I agree.


> I don't think words are working

Indeed. I have no idea what you mean by "non-local variable."

You should read this:

http://www.scottaaronson.com/democritus/lec11.html

just to make sure we're on the same page about the basics. (Pay particular attention to the part starting with "No-go theorems galore".)


Could you point out what you think that has to do with locality?

It mentions it once, to assert it as a desired axiom (and incorrectly assert that QM can be local, which it can't be). I also would argue that GR supports non-local theories well enough, in that the actual geometry can appear macro-Euclidean (or other nice space) while containing micro-bridges which break the locality structure for the "nice" macro space.

A non-local value is any value which can impact things at super-luminal speed (generally, instantaneously). Of course, I would argue that the non-locality is only apparent, and we're simply seeing the shape of things very wrong because of how brains work, the information reaches us, etc.


> A non-local value is any value which can impact things at super-luminal speed

Ah. Those are ruled out by relativity. If you can send information faster than light, then you can send information backwards in time and violate causality.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: