Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Writer claims "I am constantly told that Uber will make transit obsolete."

Who exactly are the people telling this writer that Uber will make transit obsolete? I live in a city where public transportation is very popular and have not once, ever heard this.

The reality is public transit use is surging in popularity. Public ridership is up 39% since 1995 (you know, when most people did not have internet or smartphones). Young people flock to cities with good public transit. And while I've never once heard someone say "Uber will make public transit obsolete", I have heard many people say they chose a city because it had good public transit.




The Author is a transit consultant. He is constantly talking to cities/towns about optimizing their transit networks.

I would guess he is hearing it from politicians and other parties in the areas he is talking to. They will say "Why should we spend $x on a new bus system when uber/driverless cars will solve the problem"


If he's hearing it from politicians/public officials then he should name who made such comments. Since it's the base of his argument that Uber is killing transit, it's important to cite where he heard it.


So people would move to a boring city with great public transit?


If there are good jobs there, people will move to just about anywhere, transit or no, boring or not.


It's not the only factor, but it's often mentioned as an important one.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: