Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I really dislike this sentiment "It's not terrible, you just don't understand it!" If everyone is just misunderstanding it, than it's terrible.

I write apt-packages all the time. I get the process. And yes, it's still terrible. And when you consider that devs need to know how to build for apt-get, yum, etc, it's understandable, IMO, why they don't want to bother.



> If everyone is just misunderstanding it, than it's terrible.

This is the place where I'm sure we're not talking about the same aspect of building packages.

I assumed that you were talking about Debian specifically, since the only hint to the topic was "apt-get" somewhere earlier. I thought that you were talking about the old, overcomplicated way of providing manually all the necessary targets (binary, build, install, clean) and specifying dh_{any} commands in debian/rules, possibly using underdocumented CDBS. This is what would be straightened up by the article I mentioned.

Instead, you seem to mean something about packaging on a higher level than that. Do you care to elaborate, what's terrible in building binary (or DEB) packages? I'm doing it for years and I'm yet to encounter a more sensible way of deploying software, including web applications (which are one huge inconsistent and fragile mess).

> [...] when you consider that devs need to know how to build for apt-get, yum, etc, it's understandable, IMO, why they don't want to bother.

What magic do they need to know? There are very little things for DEBs and RPMs. One thing (a common one) is to have a simple way to compile the project offline. Another (again, a common one, and not limited to packaging) is to know how your runtime and compiler (if any) allows to use libraries. Then you need to know there can be post-install scripts, which are meant to e.g. add user account for a daemon, and possibly how to write an init script. And there are two build rules skeletons to know, but those are quite short. This is the only thing which differs in a significant way. Or have I missed something in your opinion?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: