Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

We're not running out of limestone anytime soon, but otherwise this is a bit off-target. All of the alternative construction techniques you mention have advantages over reinforced concrete. Concrete also has its advantages, but TFA is not wrong about the disadvantages.

When I traveled to Philippines earlier this year I was struck by how they use masonry in situations that in USA would be reinforced concrete. Granted, the blocks are all CMUs, but the technique is masonry. I think it's because very few roads (at least in the places I traveled) would be suitable for standard 6-yard concrete trucks, whereas you can always throw a few dozen blocks on the back of a motorcycle. Of course labor costs are also a factor. However, concrete in block form is totally recyclable, while as TFA notes when poured it is not.




>We're not running out of limestone anytime soon

There was an article on HN some time ago on how we are running out of the type of sand necessary for concrete. There is apparently a big black market for sand stolen from rivers and beaches, leading to violence and environmental problems.

I was surprised the article didn't mention this.


Aren't blocks supposed to be reinforced with rebar and columns poured through? How easy are they to recycle in practice after this? Just curious.


I guess that probably happens some places. I haven't seen it though, and I recently tore down a block building for a friend who has since built a foundation with the blocks. I don't think concrete would be a great material in an earthquake in any configuration. If you have to mix up concrete for pouring anyway, I'm not sure why you'd build a wall first when you could just place some forms instead, which would take much less time.


Yes. I believe that's the code in Los Angeles.


Yeah, if you're in an earthquake zone, like the Pacific Ring of Fire (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_of_Fire), which most certainly includes California and the Philippines, you're eventually going to be very unhappy if you don't reinforce them.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: