Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>The site is also unusable on mobile, because ASCII art unlike proper semantic HTML is not easily rescalable by the browser. And it's inaccessible by users relying on screen readers, ironically because of all the ASCII cruft.

As web developers, we're used to "everyone" being the audience, but that's not the case here. As a stylized visual representation of the weather, it's fine. I dig it.

Making sure something is accessible to screen readers is generally an important thing (and could be worked on here) but I give this project a pass because the visual design is the whole point of the exercise.

And while I viewed this on mobile (and was fine for me with zooming), that clearly isn't the audience. Again, it could be improved if the author felt like it, but even if "fixed" (perhaps having morning, noon, evening, night being stacked vertically on mobile) I don't think this would be hardly anybody's goto weather reference on mobile. It's meant for us desktop users who are lovers of the terminal aesthetic.



Oh, I agree that this is really cool in terms of aesthetics.

I'm pointing out that the grandparent's comment about this being minimalistic, and comparing it to real weather apps as being absurd. If you're building a toy project aimed solely at programmers on desktop, there's a lot of things you don't have to care about. Some of those things are exactly the 'bloat' the grandparent has been complaining about.


The point wasn't necessarily this specific implementation. But the general concept of lightweight text web responses. Without several MB of JS, CSS, graphics aassets, etc.


Fair 'nuff! Thanks for the clarification. (The other stuff isn't the only source of bloat--for example, weather sites as a category feel (on average)...um...spammy (can't think of a better word) to me when it comes to quantity and presentation of ads and "suggested content"--but I get ya.)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: